Key result
Surgical supra-annular aortic tissue valves measure ~2.8 mm smaller than their labelled diameter.
Why the study?
Surgical supra-annular aortic valvar tissue prostheses are labelled inconsistently and confusingly, increasing the risk of patient-prosthesis mismatch if too small.
Does the measured inflow orifice diameter of commercially available surgical supra-annular aortic tissue valve prostheses match the manufacturer's labelled diameter as required by ISO 5840?
Does the measured inflow orifice diameter of commercially available surgical supra-annular aortic tissue valve prostheses match the manufacturer's labelled diameter as required by ISO 5840?
All commercially available surgical supra-annular bioprosthetic aortic valves have true inflow orifice diameters that are 4% to 25% smaller than their labelled diameters, highlighting an urgent need for standardized relabelling to prevent surgical sizing errors and patient-prosthesis mismatch.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Measured diameters smaller than labelled may increase mismatch risk; leaves open whether ISO-compliant relabelling reduces adverse events.
OBJECTIVES: Surgical supra-annular aortic valvar tissue prostheses are labelled in an inconsistent and confusing manner. If the replaced valve is too small for a given patient, the risk of patient-prosthesis mismatch is increased, which is associated with the risk of morbidity and mortality. The labelled diameter (LD) of these valves should coincide with the inflow orifice diameter (IOD). Therefore, our goal was to measure all relevant IODs. METHODS: Valvar design was assessed in terms of the intended position of the valve in relation to the patient's annulus. The IODs of all available supra-annular aortic valvar prostheses were measured using a conical gauge. The IODs were compared to the LDs. We searched for instructions for use, websites, packing boxes and regulatory institutions involved in the process. RESULTS: Eight valve models from 4 manufacturers were included. None of these valves were clearly labelled as supra-annular on the packing box, although for 3, the supra-annular label could be found in the written specifications. All valves had an IOD smaller than their LD, with a median difference of 15% (range: 4%-25%). The departure from LD differed per valve model and valve size. CONCLUSIONS: Valve packages should be labelled accurately and clearly so that surgeons can make a well-informed choice. Currently essential information is missing because the intended position in relation to the annulus is not consistently marked on the packing boxes, and valve sizes are labelled incorrectly. We propose a change for the better: relabel all valves according to their true IOD in a structured manner.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Boxtel et al. (2023) studied Aortic valve disease requiring surgical supra-annular bioprosthetic valve replacement (n=47). Conical gauge measurement of inflow orifice diameter (IOD) vs. Manufacturer labelled diameter (LD) according to ISO 5840 standards was evaluated on Difference between measured inflow orifice diameter (IOD) and manufacturer labelled diameter (LD) (MD 2.8 mm (median 15% oversized)). Surgical supra-annular aortic tissue valves all had a measured inflow orifice diameter smaller than their labelled diameter by a mean of 2.8 mm.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: