Why the study?
Does light to moderate alcohol consumption reduce vascular stiffness in healthy young adults?
Does light to moderate alcohol consumption reduce vascular stiffness in healthy young adults?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The editorial highlights that while light to moderate alcohol consumption may be associated with reduced aortic stiffness in women, confounding lifestyle factors and drinking patterns make causal inferences challenging.
A J-shaped relationship between alcohol consumption and mortality from coronary disease and ischaemic stroke has been described in many population studies [1,2] and has stimulated research into the possible mechanisms involved. The biggest single protective mechanism is likely to be mediated by increases in high-density lipoprotein (HDL)-cholesterol and associated apoprotein levels [3]. Other plausible mechanisms include effects on the clotting/coagulation systems with decreased platelet adhesiveness, decreased circulating fibrinogen and lipoprotein (a) levels and increased components of the fibrinolytic pathways [4,5]. More recently, decreases in C-reactive protein levels and other immune or inflammatory mediators have been described in both cross-sectional population studies and randomized controlled trials [6–8]. Antioxidant activity in wine [9], and to a lesser extent in beer [10,11], has also been proposed to play a role in cardioprotection from alcoholic beverages, particularly by those investigating the so-called ‘French Paradox’. Beneficial effects of regular alcohol drinking on insulin sensitivity and the risk of diabetes have also been reported in some population studies [12–14], although obesity is a strong confounder, and the effects on glucose tolerance could not be confirmed in a randomized controlled trial involving a reduction of alcohol consumption in regular drinkers [15]. Countering these potentially beneficial mechanisms of alcohol are its long-term blood pressure-raising effects [16], its role as a powerful pro-oxidant, which may overwhelm any antioxidant effects of different beverage types in vivo[10], pro-arrhythmic actions and, with higher doses, pro-coagulant and anti-fibrinolytic effects, myocardial depressant activity and important hazards of binge drinking [17,18]. In the context of cardioprotection, in this issue of the journal, van den Elzen et al. [19] address the possible beneficial effects of light to moderate drinking on vascular stiffness in 524 healthy young Dutch adults. The authors have previously reported that regular light to moderate alcohol consumption is associated with decreased aortic stiffness in men and postmenopausal women aged over 40 years, as assessed by pulse wave velocity from the carotid to femoral arteries [20,21]. These findings contrast with those reported in middle-aged Japanese men [22]. van den Elzen et al. [19] now report an inverse association between alcohol consumption and vascular stiffness in young women but not in young men. A number of issues arise from their study. First, because it is a cross-sectional study in nature, does the statistical association between reported alcohol drinking and pulse wave velocity observed in women represent cause and effect? If so, what is the mechanism and why is there a gender difference? The authors acknowledge that the potential weaknesses of their study include possible inaccuracies in alcohol histories, the lack of a description of drinking patterns such as binge drinking, and a lack of data on dietary factors or reliable physical activity records, all of which may be potential confounders of the relationships seen, or not seen in the case of men. Recording of alcohol intake was less than ideal and, although validated by HDL-cholesterol levels, the correlation between them was weak and inconsistent. Most of their subjects were very light to moderate drinkers and their patterns of drinking were not recorded but may be particularly relevant to vascular disease and mortality. For example, there is strong evidence for increased coronary and stroke mortality with binge drinking patterns in Eastern Europe at total average levels of alcohol consumption associated with cardioprotection in the West [23,24]. Binge drinking also is an important factor in sudden cardiac death as well as both ischaemic and haemorragic stroke in younger subjects [25]. Dietary patterns, physical activity and smoking are all strongly associated with the volume and type of alcohol consumed, as well as with drinking patterns. This was demonstrated in a recent study of lifestyle factors in middle-aged men from different regions of France, which showed that moderate alcohol drinkers and current wine drinkers had substantially healthier dietary quality, smoked less and were more physically active than abstainers [26]. They concluded that the healthy behaviours associated with low to moderate alcohol and wine consumption could be a major factor in the associated low cardiovascular morbidity and mortality rates. Also in this issue of the journal, Wildman et al. [27] reported a two-fold increased risk of both isolated systolic and systolic/diastolic hypertension in Chinese men who were drinking at least 30 alcoholic beverages a week. Because isolated systolic hypertension (ISH) reflects increased arterial stiffness in older subjects, this may be another indication of a direct vascular effect of heavier alcohol consumption working in the opposite manner to that reported with lighter drinking. However, in younger subjects, ISH may be due to increased adrenergic activity, which is another effect of alcohol, and the ages of the Chinese individuals studied were in the range 35–74 years. Furthermore, there may have been confounding by other lifestyle changes related to beverage type because liquor drinkers, who were also heavier smokers showed a specific association with isolated systolic hypertension. Notwithstanding these reservations, it is still plausible that alcohol drinking may cause reduced vascular stiffness either directly or indirectly. More direct assessments of the effects of alcohol drinking on large vessel structure and function have been made using carotid intima–media thickness (IMT) and measurement of plaque formation. One study reported an inverse association between alcohol and IMT in non-diabetics but a J-shaped relationship in those with impaired glucose tolerance [28]. Another study reported a J-shaped relation, but only in diabetics with the CC genotype of the interleukin-6 promoter polymorphism [29], suggesting that alcohol acts via inflammatory pathways. Other possible mechanisms for the effects of alcohol on vascular stiffness are increased levels or activity of metalloproteinases. Increased circulating MMP9 has been found in alcoholics [30], whereas female rats fed alcohol for 72 days showed increased MMP2 levels and decreased aortic elastin [31]. The latter results would be compatible with the heightened vascular stiffness observed at higher levels of alcohol consumption. The beneficial effects of alcohol on vascular stiffness could be mediated indirectly via a reduction in atherosclerosis due to increased HDL and reduced platelet adhesiveness to the endothelium [32]. Direct effects of alcohol for improving endothelial function have been claimed from acute studies but no effects on flow-mediated dilation could be found in a randomized controlled trial in which alcohol consumption was reduced by 80% in regular beer drinkers [33,34]. Finally, could there be gender differences with respect to the effects of alcohol on vascular stiffness in younger but not older subjects? Premenopausal women have high circulating oestrogen levels and high HDL, which may directly or indirectly affect large vessel structure and function, and possibly potentiate the effects of alcohol. However, alcohol demonstrated the same effect on aortic stiffness in postmenopausal women as it did in younger women. In a Belgian population study, gender-dependent differences were described for brachial artery distensibility but not for the aorta [35]. It appears more likely that the lack of an effect of alcohol on vascular stiffnesss in the younger men studied by van den Elzen et al. [19] was due to one or more of the following factors: (i) confounding lifestyle; (ii) unreported binge drinking; or (iii) poor statistical power. Overall, the limited literature supports an association between light to moderate drinking habits and reduced aortic stiffness. Whether this association represents a cause and effect, and comprises another mechanism by which alcohol diminishes the risk of coronary and ischaemic stroke mortality, remains tantalisingly unclear.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lawrence J. Beilin (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: