Why the study?
Does stress echocardiography combined with cardiopulmonary exercise testing improve the diagnosis of early HFpEF in subjects with normal LV ejection fraction and exertional dyspnoea?
Does stress echocardiography combined with cardiopulmonary exercise testing improve the diagnosis of early HFpEF in subjects with normal LV ejection fraction and exertional dyspnoea?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Combining stress echocardiography with cardiopulmonary exercise testing provides a comprehensive and feasible approach for the early diagnosis of HFpEF in patients with unexplained exertional dyspnoea.
Approximately half of all patients with heart failure have preserved ejection fraction, a condition whose trajectory in prevalence is increasing.1 According to consensus recommendations, a diagnosis of heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF) can be obtained when three requirements are met simultaneously: signs and symptoms of heart failure; preserved left ventricular (LV) global systolic performance (ejection fraction by echocardiography >50% and LV end-systolic volume <97 ml/m2) in the presence of impaired LV relaxation and compliance.2 An increase in LV filling pressure is an important haemodynamic signature that triggers exercise limitation and symptoms. Some HFpEF patients, however, may be misclassified, because they have virtually normal LV diastolic function and filling pressure at rest, compared with controls.3 Traditional echocardiographic indices have been insensitive for the diagnosis of HFpEF because they have tried to identify patients with breathlessness during exercise, using only resting diagnostic criteria. Diagnosis may therefore remain challenging, especially in the earlier stages when symptoms occur just during exercise and incoming dyspnoea is a sensitive but not specific marker to accomplish a diagnosis. So, exercise appears the ideal physiological condition to monitor simultaneously cardiac filling pressure by Doppler echocardiography4 and symptoms by cardiopulmonary exercise testing (CPET),5 possibly commuting the suspicion in a true diagnosis. How can this be obtained and how may the information provided by the two tests integrate with each other? In a series of 86 subjects with normal LV ejection fraction and exertional dyspnoea, Nedeljkovic and coworkers6 intriguingly address how much exercise stress echo and CPET may be synergistic in unmaking early HFpEF clinical manifestations. Previous trials in this area have been limited to an isolated echo-Doppler stress test analysis assessing the diastolic response in patients with established7–11 rather than suspected3,12 HFpEF diagnosis. In addition, the few studies combining CPET did report peak oxygen consumption (VO2) only,8,13 without a comprehensive evaluation of gas exchange measures reflective of cardiac functional reserve (oxygen pulse) and ventilatory efficiency (slope of rate of increase in ventilation to carbon dioxide production (VE/VCO2)). The only prespecified criteria for a diagnosis of HFpEF was a ratio of two-dimensional (2D) echo Doppler early mitral flow (E) and tissue Doppler imaging of early mitral annulus movement (e′) at peak exercise greater than 15, which although not a validated standard for signalling an abnormal increase in LV filling pressure during exercise, represents the cut-off identified by most.7 In the normal heart, e′ changes with rapid motion of mitral annulus along the LV long axis and occurs almost concomitant with the mitral E wave. With impairment in LV relaxation and compliance, E inflow is slowed and e′ is reduced and delayed. When diastolic dysfunction results in an increased left atrial pressure, E wave velocity increases and the augmented E/e′ indicates an increase in filling pressure providing a non-invasive indicator of diastolic heart failure. Thus, it should be realised that in patients with diastolic dysfunction that has not yet caused an increase in left atrial pressure, E/e′ is normal at rest, whereas it increases only during a ‘diastolic stress’, such as exercise. Despite this rationale and quite a large amount of evidence, most recent reports suggest that E/e′ is unreliable in measuring left atrial pressure both at rest and during exercise.14 Its calculation may be technically difficult when early and atrial filling phases become fused at the highest heart rates during exercise, and an increase in E/e′ during exercise is not specific for HFpEF because it may be caused by ischaemia15 or may be due to intrinsic infiltrative disorders. Nonetheless, changes in E/e′ from rest to exercise still remain the most frequent measurement obtained during exercise in the clinical work-up of HFpEF, and provide strong prognostic insights.9,16 As reported in Table 1,3,7–11 the results of studies overall confirm that exercise E/e′ increases on average more in suspected or confirmed HFpEF than in controls. Studies reporting the E/e′ changes from rest to exercise in patients with suspected and confirmed HFpEF versus controls with respective study results. HFpEF: heart failure with preserved ejection fraction; LV: left ventricular; RV: right ventricular; pts: patients; PH: pulmonary hypertension; LVEDP: left ventricular end-diastolic pressure; CPET: cardiopulmonary exercise testing. Studies reporting the E/e′ changes from rest to exercise in patients with suspected and confirmed HFpEF versus controls with respective study results. HFpEF: heart failure with preserved ejection fraction; LV: left ventricular; RV: right ventricular; pts: patients; PH: pulmonary hypertension; LVEDP: left ventricular end-diastolic pressure; CPET: cardiopulmonary exercise testing. In the study by Nedeljkovic et al. the number of heart failure subjects diagnosed as HFpEF, with an exercise E/e′ of 17.3 on average, was small, only 9.2%. What, however, seems reassuring is that this subset of patients presented with a series of additional abnormalities rendering the diagnosis of HFpEF more convincing, such as a higher increase in estimated exercise systolic arterial pulmonary pressure (PASP), a worse aerobic capacity, a steeper VE/VCO2 slope and a lower oxygen pulse. The reported higher PASP in the group of patients diagnosed as HFpEF is a finding poorly emphasised in the paper, but is well worthy of comment. Although stress echo evidence of exercise-induced pulmonary pressure hypertension is not diagnostic for HFpEF per se, in patients with dyspnoea with normal LV ejection fraction and without other reasons for pulmonary arterial hypertension, it may very likely be indicative of the early stages of HFpEF and is prognostic especially when associated with a E/e′ greater than 15.9 Consistently in the study by Nedeljkovic et al., patients with a E/e′ greater than 15 and increased PASP exhibited the worse functional capacity phenotype, and an elevation of both can improve the specificity of changes in E/e′ for HFpEF, thus avoiding the over-reliance on a single echocardiographic measurement during stress echo. Many mechanisms, including cardiac, vascular and metabolic factors, may contribute to reduced exercise capacity in patients with HFpEF.4 Their net result can be demonstrated during CPET in the presence of a peak VO2 that is lower than expected for the patient’s age and an increased VE/VCO2 slope.5,17–19 In heart failure of both systolic and diastolic origin an increased VE/VCO2 slope is a strong prognosticator that performs with the same predictive ability.5 Interestingly, in the present investigation the VE/VCO2 slope emerged at multivariate logistic regression analysis as the only predictor of exercise-induced evidence of HFpEF. The pathogenesis of an increased VE/VCO2 slope is complex and it is still not determined what the mechanism is that may lead to abnormal ventilation in suspected HFpEF. The study findings, however, clearly point towards the unfavourable interaction between high LV filling pressure exercise-induced pulmonary hypertension and impaired right ventricular adaptation. An additional variable worthy of consideration is oxygen pulse, that is, the ratio of VO2 to heart rate, which reflects the amount of oxygen extracted per heart beat. The oxygen pulse is used as an estimator of stroke volume (SV) during exercise.20 According to the modified Fick equation, the oxygen pulse is numerically equal to the product of SV and the arterial to mixed venous oxygen content difference, C(a-v)O2. The profile of the oxygen pulse response during exercise, therefore, reflects the product of these two variables. At a near maximal/maximal work rate, in which C(a–v)O2 is assumed to be maximal and relatively constant, the pattern of change of the oxygen pulse parallels that of SV as long as the previous assumption is correct. Therefore, a depressed oxygen pulse can be assumed to be a non-invasive indicator of the extent of cardiac reserve limitation in these patients. In conclusion, at this stage, although more exercise data are necessary to secure further advancements in the diagnostic algorithm of unexplained dyspnoea, it appears quite conceivable that the combined echo stress and CPET test approach is a feasible and comprehensive option to open a new window for both early diagnosis and research investigation of exercise unexplained dyspnoea due to the HFpEF syndrome. The author(s) received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article. The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marco Guazzi (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: