Key result
Left ventricular mechanical dyssynchrony was not independently associated with cardiovascular death or heart failure hospitalization (107 events) in patients with HFpEF.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Mechanical dyssynchrony assessed by speckle tracking echocardiography does not provide independent prognostic information in patients with HFpEF and is unlikely to be a central pathophysiological mechanism.
This article refers to ‘Prognostic importance of left ventricular mechanical dyssynchrony in heart failure with preserved ejection fraction’ by T. Biering-Sørensen et al., published in this issue on pages 1043–1052. Heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF) is a very prevalent condition and carries significant morbidity and mortality.1, 2 Despite significant advances made during the last decades in treating patients with HF and reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF), no significant change in outcomes has been noted for HFpEF patients.3 The lack of efficacy for established HFrEF therapies in HFpEF patients underscores the incomplete understanding of the pathophysiology and mechanisms driving outcomes in the setting of HFpEF. Mechanical dyssynchrony in left ventricular (LV) contraction has been established as an important pathogenic mechanism, prognostic factor and potential treatment target (when associated with electrical dyssynchrony) in patients with HFrEF.3, 4 Several authors have investigated lately the timing of systolic and diastolic events in patients with HFpEF hoping to ultimately extrapolate the benefits of cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT) seen in HFrEF to the setting of HFpEF. Studies using conventional Doppler and tissue Doppler echocardiography parameters have found a high prevalence of mechanical dyssynchrony in patients with HFpEF, regardless of QRS duration.5, 6 Recently, speckle tracking echocardiography (STE) has emerged as a useful technique for quantification of mechanical dyssynchrony, having the advantage of relative angle independence. Higher mechanical dyssynchrony was reported in patients with HFpEF compared to healthy controls, and this was seen even in patients with a narrow QRS complex (<100 ms) suggesting that dyssynchrony may play a pathophysiological role in HFpEF.7 However, even if QRS duration emerged as a phenotypic marker of adverse outcomes in patients with HFpEF,8 it remains unclear if mechanical dyssynchrony could be a clinically meaningful target for CRT. In this issue of the journal Biering-Sørensen et al.9 sought to determine whether the presence of LV mechanical dyssynchrony is simply a marker of worse cardiac function or a central pathophysiological mechanism independently associated with worse prognosis in patients with HFpEF. The study population was recruited from the 3445 patients with HFpEF enrolled in the Treatment of Preserved Cardiac Function Heart Failure With an Aldosterone Antagonist (TOPCAT) trial. Dyssynchrony analysis was performed on 424 patients (i.e. 45% of the TOPCAT echocardiographic study; and 12% of the overall study population) using several STE strain-based criteria. Mean age was 70 ± 10 years, LV ejection fraction (LVEF) was 60 ± 8%, and QRS duration was 101 ± 27 ms. During a median follow-up of 2.6 years, 107 patients experienced the composite outcome of cardiovascular death or heart failure (HF) hospitalization. The main parameter of mechanical dyssynchrony analysed was the standard deviation of the time to peak longitudinal strain. The median value obtained from the four-chamber view was 59.0 ms (interquartile range 39.5–88.5 ms). A higher mechanical dyssynchrony was significantly associated with the composite outcome in the unadjusted analysis. However, this was no longer significant after adjusting for clinical characteristics or LVEF, atrial fibrillation, NYHA class, stroke, heart rate, creatinine, haematocrit and QRS duration. Other strain-based measures of mechanical dyssynchrony were not associated with the composite outcome even in unadjusted analyses. The authors concluded that despite being of similar magnitude with other HFpEF studies, mechanical dyssynchrony did not provide independent prognostic information and it is unlikely to be an important mechanism underlying the syndrome of HFpEF. The authors should be commended for providing such interesting data in a subgroup of patients from a large HFpEF trial. Unlike some other previous dyssynchrony studies limited by the heterogeneity of echocardiographic analyses performed on different vendors' platforms, in this study all the strain information was gathered using the same software. However, these results should be read with caution for several reasons, some of them acknowledged as limitations by the authors. Strain analysis was not feasible in 55% of the TOPCAT echocardiographic studies. Moreover, when compared to those not included, selected patients presented with significantly different baseline characteristics (e.g. older, with a higher prevalence of coronary artery disease, stroke, and diabetes, having a higher NYHA class, etc.). Patients with atrial fibrillation, excluded from the vast majority of studies aiming to assess mechanical dyssynchrony, represented more than 40% of this study group, and the feasibility of accurate STE dyssynchrony analysis in this setting is reduced. Furthermore, approximately one-half of the study patients did not have strain data from both apical four- and two-chamber views, and none of them had strain data from all three apical views. As such, the results of the study cannot be easily extrapolated to the HFpEF patients in the community. Systolic dyssynchrony was the main target in the majority of HF studies assessing mechanical dyssynchrony. However, LV diastolic dyssynchrony (isolated or associated with systolic dyssynchrony), reported in HF patients irrespective of LVEF,5, 6 cannot be overlooked in patients with HFpEF, since LV diastolic dysfunction is a major pathophysiological factor in this setting. The relationship between systolic and diastolic dyssynchrony appeared weak in a study of 281 patients with systolic HF and 92 patients with diastolic HF.5 As a result, systolic and diastolic dyssynchrony were discordant in about half of the HF population in that study,5 suggesting different pathogenic mechanisms in the two HF categories. To what extent does diastolic dyssynchrony contribute to the pathophysiology and disease severity of HFpEF is a controversial matter. Previous studies showed that myocardial relaxation, an active process responsible for rapid LV pressure decay in early diastole, is normally homogeneous in all LV segments. Thus, an increase in temporal heterogeneity of myocardial relaxation could delay the timing of diastolic LV minimum pressure from early to late diastole contributing to the elevation of LV filling pressure.10, 11 Lee et al. showed that LV diastolic mechanical dyssynchrony is closely linked to diastolic dysfunction degree and to filling pressure (i.e. E/e') in patients presenting with acute coronary syndromes, suggesting that diastolic dyssynchrony may be a contributing factor for acute ischaemic HFpEF. Interestingly, such an association was not apparent for systolic mechanical dyssynchrony in that study.10 Nevertheless, previous data suggested that positive changes in diastolic function with CRT (improved LV filling, reduced filling pressures) are generally the result of haemodynamic improvement of load-dependent parameters, and are limited to patients with an abnormal haemodynamic profile at baseline.12, 13 Intrinsic LV relaxation does not appear to be impacted acutely or chronically by CRT.13, 14 The concept of atrial dyssynchrony and left atrial pacing as a potential therapeutic approach for HFpEF patients have also been investigated but despite interesting results, further research is needed before more definitive conclusions can be drawn.15 Exercise-induced torsional dyssynchrony and its relation to impaired functional capacity in patients with HFpEF were reported by Tan et al.16 However, validation and standardization of the techniques used to detect torsional dyssynchrony are needed. Assessing cardiac mechanics and haemodynamics during exercise is very sensible and logical, yet underutilized in a condition mainly characterized by exercise-induced symptoms. This also represents the background of stronger current recommendations for exercise diastology testing in symptomatic patients in whom the resting examination fails to prove the existence of high LV filling pressures.17 Keeping things simple is certainly useful for practical reasons. However, one cannot oversimplify a very complex disease process without the risk of losing in accuracy and meaning. On the other hand, the increase in complexity of proposed imaging methods (e.g. strain, rotation, twist) and the prospect of using them also during exercise make their use more challenging. These techniques may provide a wealth of useful information, but there is a need for improving standardization and reproducibility as well as defining cut-off values for specific clinical settings. For now, the prognostic significance of mechanical dyssynchrony (resting or exercise-induced) in patients with HFpEF remains unclear and needs to be further tested in studies specifically designed for this purpose. Conflict of interest: none declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Popescu et al. (2017) conducted an editorial in Heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF) (n=424). Left ventricular mechanical dyssynchrony was evaluated on Composite outcome of cardiovascular death or heart failure (HF) hospitalization. Left ventricular mechanical dyssynchrony was not independently associated with cardiovascular death or heart failure hospitalization (107 events) in patients with HFpEF.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: