Why the study?
Does mitral valve repair reduce operative mortality and improve event-free survival compared to mitral valve replacement in patients undergoing mitral valve surgery?
Does mitral valve repair reduce operative mortality and improve event-free survival compared to mitral valve replacement in patients undergoing mitral valve surgery?
Mitral valve repair is associated with lower operative mortality and improved long-term event-free survival compared to valve replacement, particularly in patients with mitral regurgitation.
Background and ObjectivesRecently, in mitral valve surgery, valvuloplasty or valve repair was successfully introduced to improve postoperative left ventricular function and to decrease operative mortality.However, the real impact of this technique on daily practice in Korea was not systematically assessed.Materials and MethodThe operative methods, postoperative death, follow-up results and their contributing factors were analysed among patients who underwent mitral valve surgery at our institution.Results1) From June 1989 to December 1996, 416 patients (186 males, mean age 4813 years) underwent mitral valve surgery.Dominant mitral stenosis (MS) was the main pathology in 167 patientsdominant mitral regurgitation (MR) and balanced mitral stenoinsufficiency (MSR) in 197 and 52 respectively.2) In MS, valve replacement was performed in 91% whereas commissurotomy in 9%.However, in MR, the rates of valve repair surgery has increased up to 60% of the total surgical procedures for the past three years.3) The overall operative mortality was 4% (18/416).It was significantly lower in valve repair compaired with valve replacement (0% vs. 6%p0.003).In MS, factors associated with high mortality were longer cardiopulmonary bypass and aortic cross clamp time.In MR, high mortality was associated with diabetes, endocarditis, valve replacement and longer cardiopulmonary bypass time.4) The 7-year late survival among operative survivors was 952% in MS, which was singnificantly higher than that in MR (806%, p0.04).5) In MR, the 4-year cardiac event-free survival among operative survivors (absence of cardiac death, reoperation, bleeding, endocarditis, thromboembolism, or development of heart failure) was significantly higher in valve repair group than in valve replacement (847 vs. 765%p0.03).ConclusionThe overall outcomes of recent mitral valve surgery were satisfactory.In MR, valve repair surgery seemed to be an established method to decrease operative mortality and long-term complications.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Song et al. (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: