Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
American Jersey Cattle Chtb"Nicking" has been the subject of considerable discussion among breeders for many years.Generally speaking, this term is applied to those cases where the progeny from certain matings appear superior to those from other rantings of the same animal or families.Webster defines nicking as follows : " I n stock breeding, to combine well."Breeders are constantly seeking to improve both type and production.In doing so they try different outcross matings, linebred matings, and inbred rantings, hoping to purify or intensify desirable qualities.When one of these types of matings appears superior to the others it is said to " n i c k ."This factor of superior progeny has been noticed in other types of livestock.In Herefords it is a recognized fact that when Anxiety IV was mated to daughters of North Pole, the resulting progeny were much superior to those of other matings.In Standard Bred horses the crossing of the descendants of Peter the Great with those of Axwortlly has given such superior, uniform progeny that it is known as the Golden Cross.Hervey and Heizer (1) have shown in comparing daughter-dam groups of the various matings of three Guernsey sires that certain crosses resulted in significant differences in production.They attribute these differences to nicking.Fohrman and Graves (2) made a study of the daughters o£ 51 Ayrshire sires.In one case they found that the daughters of Sire 36 out of dams by Sire 11 averaged higher in production than did those daughters of Sire 36 out of dams by miscellaneous sires.In direct contrast to this an editorial in Hoard's Dairyman (3), in discussing nicking, states that the Pennsylvania State College has records of 100 proved bulls in which it finds that those proved to be prepotent in one herd were prepotentin other herds and vice versa.These conflicting opinions raise the question: "Will a bull proved to transmit high producing capacity in one herd be equally successful in another herd where a different family blood line exists ?"
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Johnson et al. (1940) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: