Key result
The HeartBeat smartphone algorithm failed to meet ESH-IP2 accuracy standards for blood pressure measurement, showing no significant correlation with manual measurements.
Why the study?
To determine whether the HeartBeat smartphone algorithm calculates blood pressure as accurately as required by the ESH-IP2 validation protocol.
Does the HeartBeat smartphone algorithm accurately calculate blood pressure compared to standard manual measurement in a general adult population?
Observational (n=62)
Blinded observers
No
Does the HeartBeat smartphone algorithm accurately calculate blood pressure compared to standard manual measurement in a general adult population?
The tested smartphone-based photoplethysmography algorithm was not sufficiently accurate for remote blood pressure monitoring in a general adult population.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Alerts clinicians against using this unvalidated algorithm; leaves open need for improved photoplethysmography validation studies.
BACKGROUND: Outside of a clinical setting, oscillometric devices make remote monitoring of blood pressure and virtual care more convenient and feasible. HeartBeat Technologies Ltd developed a novel approach to measuring blood pressure remotely after an initial blood pressure reading by a nurse using the conventional measurement method. Using a finger pulse oximeter, a photoplethysmogram wave is transmitted by Bluetooth to a smartphone or tablet. A smartphone app (MediBeat) transmits the photoplethysmogram to a server for analysis by a proprietary algorithm-the person's current blood pressure is sent back to the smartphone and to the individual's health care provider. OBJECTIVE: This study sought to determine whether the HeartBeat algorithm calculates blood pressure as accurately as required by the European Society of Hypertension International Protocol revision 2010 (ESH-IP2) for validation of blood pressure measuring devices. METHODS: ESH-IP2 requirements, modified to conform to a more recent international consensus statement, were followed. The ESH-IP2 establishes strict guidelines for the conduct and reporting of any validation of any device to measure blood pressure, including using the standard manual blood pressure instrument as a comparator and specific required accuracy levels for low, medium, and high ranges of blood pressure readings. The consensus statement requires a greater number of study participants for each of the blood pressure ranges. The validation of the accuracy of the algorithm was conducted with a Contec CMS50EW pulse oximeter and a Samsung Galaxy XCover 4 smartphone. RESULTS: The differences between the HeartBeat-calculated and the manually measured blood pressures of 62 study participants did not meet the ESH-IP2 standards for accuracy for either systolic or diastolic blood pressure measurements. There was no discernible pattern in the inaccuracies of the HeartBeat-calculated measurements. CONCLUSIONS: The October 4, 2019 version of the HeartBeat algorithm, implemented in combination with the MediBeat app, a pulse oximeter, and an Android smartphone, was not sufficiently accurate for use in a general adult population. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov NCT04082819; http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT04082819.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Holyoke et al. (2021) conducted an observational in Hypertension (n=62). HeartBeat algorithm with MediBeat app and pulse oximeter vs. Manual aneroid sphygmomanometer with stethoscope was evaluated on Accuracy of blood pressure measurement according to ESH-IP2 standards (r=0.04, p=0.53). The HeartBeat smartphone algorithm failed to meet ESH-IP2 accuracy standards for blood pressure measurement, showing no significant correlation with manual measurements.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: