Why the study?
How does the Ortho ELT-8 automated blood counter compare to the Coulter Counter Model S in measuring blood cell parameters?
How does the Ortho ELT-8 automated blood counter compare to the Coulter Counter Model S in measuring blood cell parameters?
The Ortho ELT-8 provides generally comparable blood count results to the Coulter Counter Model S, but users should be aware of specific discrepancies in WBC, PCV, and red cell indices.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Requires awareness of discrepancies before clinical reliance on Ortho ELT-8; leaves open need for standardized validation protocols.
The Ortho ELT-8 is an automated blood counter which appears to be safe, precise and free from carry-over. Red and white cell results generally agree with those on the Coulter Counter, Model S, though discrepancies were noted with the WBC and PCV. Reference methods showed the Model S WBC results tended to be inaccurate on the discrepant samples though neither instrument was predominantly responsible for the PCV discrepancies. The ELT-8 platelet count tended to be higher than with the Thrombocounter/Thrombofuge system. When packed cells were diluted in autologous plasma serious variations in the red cell indices (MCV, MCH & MCHC) were first found due to incorrect voltage-frequency converter setting. Even after this setting had been corrected some variations in the MCH and MCHC were still apparent. In the UK National External Quality Assessment Scheme the ELT-8 results on animal bloods did not agree with those produced by Model S users; this discrepancy probably being due to differences between the light-scattering and aperture-impedance technology.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
England et al. (2008) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: