Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Between November 2003 and February 2004, an outbreak of legionnaires disease occurred in the Pas-de-Calais region of northern France. There were 18 deaths among the total of 86 cases found within a radius of ∼10 km around a petrochemical plant that was the probable source of contamination [1] From January to March 2004, we sampled aerosols produced by industrial cooling towers and by an industrial sludge water treatment basin to search for Legionella bacteria by use of a new experimental method. To date, management of this serious biological risk has relied solely on the monitoring of water quality. The only known contamination vector is the aerosol, and the transfer function between contaminated water and air remains unknown. Our contribution, which is based on the collection of large volumes of aerosols and the detection of Legionella bacteria by fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH), offers an interesting new approach, leading to more realistic information about human exposure to these pathogens Aerosol sampling was performed on 5 cooling towers from different plants and on an aerated sludge water treatment basin. Aerosol sampling was performed directly above the fan of the cooling towers, on the edge of the basin close to the aerators, and at some distance downwind and upwind of the basin. Two sampling series, 1 with and 1 without the aerators being operated, were performed An experimental bioaerosol collector (a cyclone-like device) was used to collect the airborne bacteria. The aerosols penetrated the sampler tangentially to the cyclone wall where they impacted. The wall was constantly washed by a filtered (0.2-μm pores) deionized water flow (160 mL) that circulated in closed loop, so as to concentrate the collected aerosol particles. The cutoff diameter of the experimental cyclone was 0.9 μm, with a collection efficiency of 100% for aerosols ⩾1.2 μm. Sampling was done under controlled airflow conditions (1 m3/min during 40 min; total air flow, 40 m3) Airborne Legionella bacteria were quantified by FISH [2, 3], as adapted from the method described by Manz et al. [4], using a mix of 3 specific probes validated for Legionella bacteria—LEG705 (5′-cTggTgTTccTTccgATc-3′), LEG226 (5′-TcggAcgcAggcTAATcT-3′), and LEGPNE1 (5′-ATcTgAccgTcccAggTT-3′)—that were labeled with CY3 dye (Eurogentec) at the 5′ end. This method yields results within 48 h (vs. 14 days for the standard method). In parallel with the FISH method, the cultivable fraction of aerosolized Legionella bacteria was evaluated using the standard method [5]. Last, 4′,6-diamidino-2-phenylindol (DAPI) was used to evaluate the total number of airborne bacteria, by counting under an epifluorescence microscope (Olympus) [6] All investigated sites generated bioaerosols with concentrations of bacteria ranging from 1×105 to 1×106 cells/m3 (DAPI staining). Among these airborne bacteria, Legionella bacteria were detected by FISH at all sites. Nevertheless, Legionella bacteria represented a small fraction—between 0.05% and 0.9%—of the total airborne biocontaminants. Moreover, no cultivable Legionella bacteria could be detected using the standard method, even when the use of FISH showed that there were concentrations of ∼1×103Legionella cells/m3 (table 1) Bioaerosol measurements performed on 5 industrial cooling towers and close to an industrial sludge water treatment basin with (sampling series 1) and without (sampling series 2) aeration A remarkable result was obtained with the bioaerosols generated from the sludge water treatment basin operated with aeration; cultivable Legionella bacteria were detected at the same level as that found using the FISH method. This important finding enabled us to establish for the first time, to our knowledge, that there is a direct relationship between the epidemic L. pneumophila strain and that found in the aerosols collected close to the aerated basin: airborne L. pneumophila presented the same profile of macrorestriction of genomic DNA as the epidemic strain detected in patients [1] Aeration of the sludge water treatment basin induced a diffusion of contaminated aerosols in the study zone, with, however, a decrease of the airborne Legionella concentration of a factor of 10 at 270 m downwind of the basin. At this distance, the airborne Legionella concentration, primarily L. pneumophila serogroup 1, still reached 1×102 cfu/m3. Even with moderate aeration of the sludge water treatment basin (during the second sampling series), aerosols were generated with bacterial concentrations that were significantly higher (∼2-fold) downwind than upwind of the basin. However, compared with the concentrations that were found when the aerators were operating (during the first sampling series), a 2-log reduction in Legionella concentrations and an absence of cultivable Legionella bacteria, resulting in a lower dissemination of these bacteria in the air, was found in the aerosols when the aerators were not operating Our investigations during the outbreak of legionnaires disease in Pas-de-Calais enabled us to perform in situ sampling of aerosolized Legionella bacteria by use of novel methods and demonstrated, for the first time, that there was a relationship between the suspected contamination source and the epidemic strain. Sampling of airborne Legionella bacteria emitted by cooling towers and sludge water treatment basins, coupled with whole-cell FISH detection, offers more realistic information on human exposure to these bacteria than does standard water analysis
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mathieu et al. (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: