Why the study?
Do alternative pulse oximeter probes (ear, nose, forehead) perform as well as finger probes in poorly perfused patients?
Do alternative pulse oximeter probes (ear, nose, forehead) perform as well as finger probes in poorly perfused patients?
Finger probes are recommended over alternative sites (ear, nose, forehead) for pulse oximetry in patients with poor peripheral perfusion due to superior accuracy.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Finger probes may outperform alternatives in poor perfusion; hypothesis-generating and should not yet change practice.
The performances of 10 pulse oximeters using finger probes were compared with the same pulse oximeters using alternative probes (eight finger probes, two nose probes and a forehead probe) in poorly perfused patients. All readings were then compared with directly measured arterial blood oxygen saturations. The mean difference (bias, 'accuracy'), standard deviation (precision) and 'drop out' rate for each pulse oximeter combination was determined. An overall ranking of performance of each pulse oximeter was calculated using five criteria (accuracy, precision, number of readings within 3% of standard, percentage of readings given within 3% of standard, expected overread limit in 95% of cases). Nose and forehead probes performed poorly. Some ear probes performed well compared to some finger probes, but the overall performance of probes in other sites compared to finger probes was worse, (p = 0.05). Two of eight ear probes and no nose or forehead probes would be expected to be within 4% of the reference value in 95% of readings. The use of finger probes rather than probes in other sites is recommended in the patient with poor peripheral perfusion.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Clayton et al. (1991) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: