Why the study?
Does immersion of the hand in ice water for 10 minutes distinguish paramyotonia congenita from myotonia congenita on EMG?
Does immersion of the hand in ice water for 10 minutes distinguish paramyotonia congenita from myotonia congenita on EMG?
Immersion of the hand in ice water for 10 minutes provides an unambiguous electromyographic distinction between paramyotonia congenita and myotonia congenita.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Ice-water immersion may aid EMG distinction in this case; leaves open validation in prospective cohorts before clinical adoption.
We studied three patients with paramyotonia congenita and three with myotonia congenita. At room temperature myotonic bursts in the EMG were similar in the two disorders. After repetitive maximal contractions, patients with paramyotonia showed decreasing recruitment pattern and increasing after-activity, while myotonia patients showed unchanged recruitment pattern, and after-activity tended to decrease, but these differences were not consistent. However, immersion of the hand in ice water for 10 minutes caused unambiguous differences: In paramyotonia, the myotonic discharges disappeared and the muscles went into stiff, electrically silent, contracture; in myotonia patients, the myotonic activity increased and muscle contraction patterns remained normal.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nielsen et al. (1982) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: