Why the study?
How do long-term outcomes compare among caged-ball, tilting-disc, and porcine biological mitral valve prostheses in patients with isolated mitral disease?
How do long-term outcomes compare among caged-ball, tilting-disc, and porcine biological mitral valve prostheses in patients with isolated mitral disease?
Long-term follow-up of mitral prostheses demonstrates that porcine bioprostheses have significantly lower freedom from valve-related morbidity and mortality at 10 years compared to mechanical valves, primarily driven by higher valve failure rates.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Porcine bioprostheses were associated with inferior 10-year outcomes; leaves open optimal mitral prosthesis selection pending randomized data.
Three hundred eighty-five valve prostheses were implanted between 1974 and 1981 in patients with isolated mitral disease: 157 caged-ball valves (156 Starr-Edwards; 1 Smeloff-Cutter) (group A), 107 tilting-disc valves (44 Bjork-Shiley, 49 Sorin, 14 Lillehei-Kaster) (group B), 121 porcine bioprostheses (45 Carpentier-Edwards, 66 Liotta, 10 Hancock) (group C). Perioperative mortality was 9.5% in group A, 11.2% in group B and 6.6% in group C. The follow-up was 86% complete. Actuarial freedom from complications was calculated as follows (linearised rates in brackets) in groups A, B and C, respectively: survival: 47.01% +/- 0.11 (3% patient/yr), 53.37% +/- 0.08 (1.8% patient/yr), 61.24% +/- 0.05 (2.2% patient/yr); thromboembolism: 67.94% +/- 0.09 (1.18% patient/yr); 73.07% +/- 0.06 (1% patient/yr); 97.43% +/- 0.02 (0.02% patient/yr); anticoagulation-related hemorrhage: 84.10% +/- 0.13 (0.18% patient/yr), 97.21% +/- 0.01 (0.12% patient/yr), 100%; prosthetic valve endocarditis: 100% in groups A and B, 95.76% +/- 0.02 (0.18% patient/yr) in group C; valve-related mortality: 87.52% +/- 0.03 (0.75% patient/yr), 87.96% +/- 0.03 (0.56% patient/yr), 82.53% +/- 0.04 (0.93% patient/yr); valve failure: 81.22% +/- 0.07 (0.56% patient/yr), 63.36% +/- 0.1 (1.06% patient/yr), 14.31% +/- 0.05 (4% patient/yr); treatment failure: 78.81% +/- 0.05 (1.12% patient/yr), 76.44% +/- 0.09 (0.62% patient/yr), 80.97% +/- 0.04 (1% patient/yr); all valve-related morbidity and mortality: 40.43% +/- 0.13 (1.93% patient/yr), 57.76% +/- 0.08 (1.43% patient/yr), 14.96% +/- 0.05 (4.18% patient/yr); all valve-related morbidity and mortality at 5 years: 91.97% +/- 0.02 (7.8% patient/yr), 87.06% +/- 0.03 (3.6% patient/yr), 90.27% +/- 0.03 (2.6% patient/yr); at 10 years: 80.4% +/- 0.03 (4.6% patient/yr), 75.91% +/- 0.03 (2.6% patient/yr), 37.44% +/- 0.05 (4.18% patient/yr).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Vitale et al. (1995) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: