Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Bhermi and coauthors1 have observed that bovine lens epithelial cells (LECs) migrate despite the square-edged profile (discontinuous bend in the capsule) of the culture well and climb along the well wall perpendicular to the well bottom and grow out of the well. They conclude that a discontinuous bend in the capsule in isolation is unlikely to be responsible for the observed reduction in posterior capsule opacification (PCO). In cell culturing, when the culture is confluent, the cells, at least those in the primary culture, can form multilayers in the well bottom but they do not climb along the well wall in a monolayer. In thousands of cultures, I have never observed cells climbing. Have the authors observed this finding in a conventional well? This fact can be observed daily in any laboratory. The illustration in Figure 4 showing the authors' observation that the LECs migrated along the perpendicular wall in a monolayer or a few layers strongly suggests that the LECs they used might have changed their nature (DNA change) during several passages in culture before the cells were eventually plated into the well. I will present another in vivo example indicating that LECs will form multilayers but not migrate along the capsule (well wall) when the cells find a discontinuous angle situation.2,3Figure 1 shows a lens capsule with LECs 3 weeks after surgery in a rabbit that received a capsule-bending ring (a type of capsular tension ring with a square cross section [0.7 mm × 0.2 mm] with a sharp edge). The LECs inside the ring, which may have migrated or been spontaneously dispersed onto the ring intraoperatively and postoperatively, proliferated and formed thick multilayers, but they never migrated into the posterior capsule. The profile formed by both capsules and the capsule bending ring will correspond to a rectangular well and is definitely analogous to the LEC culture in vitro. This in vivo finding is consistent with the “discontinuous capsule bend” theory. This finding and the in vitro observation that LECs do not climb the well wall are a fact, and the phenomenon cannot be denied or negated by the results of Bhermi and coauthors. Their observation should therefore be regarded as a very special in vitro phenomenon (several passages of cell cultures, unconventional wells) that contradicts the discontinuous bend theory.Figure 1.: (Nishi) Left: Proliferation of LECs in a rabbit lens capsule that received a capsule-bending ring (CBR). The LECs on the CBR formed multilayers but did not migrate onto the posterior capsule (PC) (AC = anterior capsule). The rabbit capsule is always in the vertical position. Right: Lens epithelial cells in culture. The figure on the left is analogous to LECs in the well with a rectangular bottom (below right). Reprinted with permission from Ophthalmic Surg Lasers2 and J Cataract Refract Surg.4I agree with the authors that the preventive effect of an intraocular lens (IOL) on PCO is multifactorial and that the pressure exerted by the sharp edge on the posterior capsule may also be contributory. I think the discontinuous bend theory and the pressure-on-capsule theory are 2 sides of the same coin. The sharper the edge, the greater the pressure, and therefore the sharper the capsular bend that is really present as a histopathologic fact. However, it is important that a theory explain all the phenomena and findings easily, simply, and consequently, as the capsule bending theory does for PCO. There is no evidence supporting Sigmund Freud's theory, but psychotherapy according to his theory can successfully treat patients, making his theory valuable and meaningful. In conclusion, we have 2 contradictory observations that support and oppose the capsule-bending theory. We should therefore think scientifically about the reason for the contradiction.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Okihiro Nishi (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: