Key result
A 'perfect' Fontan operation yielded predicted survival rates declining to 73% at 15 years, with a late rising hazard phase and declining functional capacity, indicating the procedure is palliative.
Why the study?
What are the early and long-term survival and functional outcomes after a "perfect" Fontan operation in patients with congenital heart disease?
Observational
What are the early and long-term survival and functional outcomes after a "perfect" Fontan operation in patients with congenital heart disease?
The Fontan operation is palliative rather than curative, characterized by a late decline in survival and functional status inherent to the Fontan state itself.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Even perfect Fontan shows late survival and functional decline; supports inherent palliative nature and informs surveillance and intervention trials.
A study was undertaken to determine the early and long-term outcomes dictated by the Fontan state per se (a state in which the force driving pulmonary blood flow is solely or largely a residue, in the systemic venous pressure, of the main ventricular chamber's contractile force) and the transition (by surgery) to it from the state of congenital heart disease under optimal conditions (after a "perfect" Fontan operation). The primary study design used a solution of a multivariate risk factor equation for death, by which survival rate under optimal conditions was predicted to be 92%, 89%, 88%, 86%, 81%, and 73% at 1 month, 6 months, and 1, 5, 10, and 15 years, respectively, after the Fontan operation. The hazard function (instantaneous risk of death at each moment in time after the operation) had an early rapidly declining phase of hazard that at about 6 months began to give way to a late hazard phase, which was rising by about 6 years after surgery. A secondary study design, using the theory of competing risks, yielded survival and hazard function information very similar to that of the primary study design. The functional capacity of the patients as expressed by New York Heart Association class was less, the longer the period of follow-up. No risk factors (other than older age at time of surgery) were found for the late decline in survival or the decline in functional status. The inference is that the premature decline in survival and functional status and the late rise in hazard function are from the Fontan state per se and that the Fontan operation is, therefore, palliative but not curative.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fontán et al. (1990) conducted an observational in congenital heart disease. Fontan operation was evaluated on survival rate. A 'perfect' Fontan operation yielded predicted survival rates declining to 73% at 15 years, with a late rising hazard phase and declining functional capacity, indicating the procedure is palliative.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: