Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The literature dealing with the value of various fats and oils in nutrition is very extensive, yet but few studies have been reported comparing their feeding value with butterfat for young calves.This fact is rather unusual considering the obvious practical value of such information in relation to economical calf raising and especially to profitable veal production.The studies reported have largely been confined to a comparatively few oils and fats and results have generally been unfavorable.Lindsey (7) using calves several months old reported generally favorable results from feeding "oleo" at the rate of one ounce per quart of skim milk and mixed thoroughly.He states, "Scarcely any of the calves were able to take more than this amount per quart without disturbing their digestion."Other products used were corn oil and cottonseed oil, but these could be fed only at the rate of one-half ounce per quart of skim milk "without producing bad effects."A calf fed a combination of corn oil and cottonseed oil seemed to thrive at first but later its condition became less favorable and when slaughtered the carcass "contained very little fat."Hendricks (5), also reported less growth in calves fed cottonseed oil and skim milk than in those fed whole milk or skim milk and cod liver oil.Leach and Golding (6) using calves 15 to 22 days old fed pilchard oil homogenized into skim milk.Severe scouring developed but increases in weight continued during the first week, then their condition became unsatisfactory and in no case did a calf live more than three weeks.Rats on a similar diet grew satisfactorily and produced litters of living young.Sehmalfuss and co-workers (11) found emulsified coconut oil to be equal to cod liver oil for feeding to calves.Similarly, Fingerling (3) found that emulsified peanut oil was a satisfactory supplement to skim milk for calves provided it was not added in too great amounts.In 1939 we (4) reported, very briefly, our results obtained from feeding calves butter oil, lard, corn oil, cottonseed oil and soybean oil, respectively, homogenized into skim milk.The results as measured in terms of rate of gain in weight, physical appearance and general well-being of calves indicated clearly the superior nutritive value of butterfat over all the other fats and oils tested.The calves fed lard made nearly as rapid gains in weight Received for publication September 22, 1941.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gullickson et al. (1942) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: