Key result
While empirical evidence is lacking, theoretical justifications suggest cognitive and psychosocial benefits of consistent surgical teams, laying groundwork for future research.
Why the study?
Do consistent surgical teams improve team performance compared to inconsistent teams?
Do consistent surgical teams improve team performance compared to inconsistent teams?
This review highlights the theoretical benefits of maintaining consistent surgical teams to improve performance, despite a current lack of empirical evidence.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Theoretical benefits of consistent surgical teams should not yet change practice; leaves open the need for empirical validation.
Surgical team members are typically defined by professional roles. In many surgical teams, membership changes as staffing decisions are subject to considerations other than keeping surgical teams consistent. These considerations may include staffing patterns on the day of surgery and at the time of a surgical case. Teamwork skill training and safety culture have been emphasized, although much is known about the contribution to team performance from team consistency. We review the literature on cognitive and psychosocial benefits of consistent surgical teams. Although empirical evidence base for consistent surgical teams is lacking, we believe that the theoretical justifications may lay the groundwork for future research on the impact of deliberate staffing decisions by organizations, to complement the current emphasis on individual teamwork knowledge, skills and attitude. We also outline some of barriers based on our experience in our respective healthcare organizations.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Xiao et al. (2014) conducted a review in Surgical team performance. Consistent surgical teams was evaluated. While empirical evidence is lacking, theoretical justifications suggest cognitive and psychosocial benefits of consistent surgical teams, laying groundwork for future research.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: