Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Closed tibial shaft fractures are the most common long-bone fractures, resulting in approximately 77,000 hospitalizations, 569,000 hospital days (average length of stay, 7.4 days), and 825,000 office visits per year 1. Closed tibial shaft fractures in young patients are most commonly sport-related injuries, whereas simple falls cause most of the closed tibial shaft fractures in the elderly. The fracture pattern of closed tibial fractures is usually simple, with less severe soft-tissue injury than is seen with open tibial shaft fractures 2. The more complex fracture configurations are frequently seen in older, less fit patients with osteoporotic bone 2. Classification of Tibial Shaft Fractures There are several ways to classify closed tibial shaft fractures, depending on whether the goal is to communicate the bone injury (fracture pattern) or the soft-tissue injury associated with the fracture. Most surgeons classify tibial shaft fractures with simple descriptive terms such as proximal, middle, or distal in addition to transverse, oblique, spiral, segmental, or comminuted. The benefits of a simple classification such as this are familiarity with the terms and a high degree of understanding of what the terms represent. The disadvantages are ambiguity and subjectivity, which make simple classifications less useful for publication and research purposes. The two most commonly used classification systems are the AO/OTA (Arbeitsgemeinschaft für Osteosynthesefragen/Orthopaedic Trauma Association) classification of bone injury 3 and the Tscherne and Gotzen classification 4 of soft-tissue injury associated with closed tibial shaft fractures. The AO/OTA classification is an alphanumeric system based on the bone involved and the particular region of the bone involved 3. Generally, the letters A, B, and C are used to designate groups of fractures of increasing severity. These groups are then subdivided, with the numbers 1, 2, and 3 indicating increasing complexity (i.e., comminution) within groups 3. Tscherne and Gotzen described four types of soft-tissue injury (0, 1, 2, and 3) associated with fractures 4. Type 0 represents minimal soft-tissue damage resulting from an indirect mechanism of injury that has caused a simple bone fracture. A type-1 injury is a superficial abrasion or soft-tissue contusion caused by pressure from the bone injury with a mild to moderately severe fracture pattern. A type-2 injury is typified by a deep contaminated abrasion associated with localized skin and muscle contusion, an impending compartment syndrome, and a high-energy fracture pattern. Finally, a type-3 injury involves extensive skin contusion or crushing, underlying severe muscle damage, a compartment syndrome, and a severe fracture pattern. Indications for Nonoperative or Operative Treatment To determine the appropriate treatment for these injuries, the surgeon should consider the many factors that lead to disability following a closed tibial shaft fracture, such as delayed union, nonunion, infection, nerve injury, contracture, and angular deformity, and choose the method of treatment that minimizes these problems. Orthopaedic surgeons do not agree on how much deviation from anatomic alignment is acceptable for a good functional outcome 5. On the basis of a long-term review of the cases of thirty-seven patients with a tibial shaft fracture treated with a cast, Merchant and Dietz concluded that "the clinical and radiographic outcomes were unaffected by the amounts of anterior or posterior and of varus or valgus angulation. . . ." 6 Despite this finding, various standards have been proposed by numerous authors 6-14 as guidelines for "acceptable alignment." Bridgman and Baird found that, depending on the parameters used to define alignment, 4% or 42% of the tibiae in their study would be considered malaligned 7. Therefore, published alignment parameters are guidelines at best, with no substantiated scientific data to support them. In addition to avoiding factors that lead to disability, surgeons choosing among treatment options must consider other goals, including simple management, early weight-bearing, early range of motion of the knee and ankle, early return to work, and cost-effectiveness. In a survey performed at the Orthopaedic Trauma Association meeting in 1997 15, Khalily et al. asked participants to indicate their preferred method of treatment of a closed, nondisplaced midshaft tibial fracture. Although most respondents favored intramedullary nailing, a large percentage chose cast treatment. Khalily et al. concluded that there was no consensus regarding optimal treatment of closed midshaft tibial fractures, even among trauma experts. Littenberg et al. performed a meta-analysis of the literature on closed tibial shaft fractures in an attempt to determine whether operative or nonoperative treatment was more appropriate 16. Only nineteen of 2372 reports met the authors' strict inclusion criteria, and those studies provided strong comparative data indicating that nonoperative treatment was more likely to prevent infection and that open reduction and internal fixation was more likely to result in union. There were too few studies available for Littenberg et al. to evaluate intramedullary nailing at the time that they conducted the meta-analysis. Their conclusion was that the data from the published literature were inadequate for decision-making with regard to the treatment of closed tibial shaft fractures. Despite this discouraging lack of guidance from the literature, two classic case series give surgeons some information that can help them to decide between operative and nonoperative treatment. In 1995, Sarmiento et al. reported on their extensive experience with functional bracing, which included 1000 consecutive closed tibial fractures 12. That experience seemed to indicate that the initial degree of displacement of the fracture is predictive of the degree of final deformity after treatment. On the basis of this premise, patients were selected for functional bracing only if they had a transverse fracture that could be reduced or if they had <15 mm of initial shortening. On the average, the duration of treatment with a long leg cast was 3.7 weeks (range, 1.4 to twenty-three weeks). The fractures healed in a mean of 18.1 weeks (range, 6.7 to weeks). The was Although of the tibiae had some only of them had of of the tibiae healed with varus deformity, only had of varus angulation. healed with some degree of anterior or posterior had of was to treatment in of the cases of angulation. Sarmiento et al. several factors that were or associated with 12. and fracture were associated with a time to union. the of an had and was associated with more union, was associated with an of In to the of the of the is the to which fracture in make factors to other factors that the of were or severe displacement in the of other factors the of delayed or from to in the of other factors the of delayed or from to soft-tissue In the of other associated soft-tissue the of delayed and from to was the most the of the were associated with delayed or not the or the of an to be associated with delayed or in study was the that patients with or severe had a of that was than that in patients and that with a cast for a of time only The a with or severe soft-tissue damage was for a long the studies by and Sarmiento et al. that fractures, whether open or closed, that are associated with more severe soft-tissue are less likely to do with cast treatment. The to treatment of closed tibial shaft fractures with a cast or is intramedullary nailing of closed tibial shaft fractures has been reported to be in terms of high and are of two studies the outcome of closed tibial fractures after cast with that after intramedullary In a clinical et al. reported that treatment of tibial fractures with intramedullary nailing in a with more union, less and return to work, than nonoperative treatment of such fractures In a et al. reported the of a outcome of patients in an fracture of the tibial shaft had been treated with intramedullary fixation or cast The two treatment groups were in terms of fracture and The that the fractures treated with the intramedullary nailing healed with with with than the fractures treated with a In a of of patients were for an of those treated with intramedullary nailing were found to have to the the and the The authors concluded that closed intramedullary nailing functional than of a cast for many patients have a closed fracture of the tibial on the benefits of intramedullary fixation and cast for the treatment of nondisplaced fractures the outcome of studies that are in In the of cast intramedullary fixation a of infection, few with knee and no for the of intramedullary nailing of alignment and the to an early range of motion of the knee and ankle, of the the for less and return to the for nonoperative treatment of tibial shaft fractures fractures with minimal soft-tissue injury 0 and to the system of Tscherne and Gotzen 4 a fracture as by of of of and of and the to in a cast or functional the for operative treatment of tibial shaft fractures a high-energy to severe soft-tissue an fracture as by of of of and of an open compartment an an to and an must be of their The literature that the outcome of intramedullary nailing of tibial fractures be than the outcome of nonoperative treatment of such fractures. cast treatment is then the surgeon must be at cast and the must be to frequently for and treatment. of Treatment with a has been that the of an cast is as and as much as internal fixation choosing closed management, should be that is for the particular and that there is no of a compartment the reduction if or has a transverse fracture with or is to the muscle for a can be used the fracture not The in a cast for the treatment of a tibial fracture is to a cast the A can be used to the leg the of a In this to the fracture and the for reduction is can be the and the can be to a of to and help to the leg in the reduced an can the The cast is the with the in and the fracture is the cast is to the of the with the knee that can be 4 the fracture is less the cast be with the knee to in to must be in the region of the to a good fit of the cast to the distal of the 4 The cast should then be in the anterior to for and the should be to as the initial The and are the which is to in the of the is to prevent the cast from with Fractures of the tibial and of the and is to with the in is then the knee with the in a with Fractures of the tibial and of the of the of a with a tibial fracture. A of can be to the the to if no is with Fractures of the tibial and of the for of a cast for the treatment of a tibial fracture. the and is by a of to the with with Fractures of the tibial and of the the initial cast has been should be to two weeks for approximately four weeks to of the should the that length the reduction most likely be The fracture to the found on the initial or of reduction a closed reduction with of be the is to and the has the long leg cast is to a cast or a the fracture not the for acceptable alignment and more than or two are to acceptable alignment, or if the fracture more than a of nonoperative treatment should be for Operative Treatment of Closed Tibial Shaft Fractures options are available for the of closed tibial shaft fractures. These many of intramedullary and of which be in the following Indications consider intramedullary to be the of for the of tibial shaft fractures, whether they are open or closed and Generally, are preferred they The of has much Although have after with that after no there is no in within the fracture or in the of bone et al. leg and after nailing in patients to or tibial nailing and found no that the of leg studies have that nailing is even for open tibial fractures, and that the of less and used for the treatment of closed fractures, intramedullary nailing is associated with a of delayed and than is intramedullary nailing The with has been the of of be less of a with in the experience of of the of of these has been the and of fractures of the tibial and A fracture pattern such as this is an for intramedullary reduction and of the fracture with an intramedullary There are several to intramedullary These the 1. intramedullary of or which In this or fixation is tibial are not to of patients have of mm in 2. of the 3. soft-tissue injury such that is 4. of the as a result of a 5. knee or knee Tibial Fractures The of tibial has the for nailing to and distal fractures of the that are the intramedullary fixation of tibial fractures is associated with a much of than is intramedullary fixation of midshaft fractures to of patients have after nailing of a closed tibial fracture and such have been to cause disability is even more common the fracture is in the of the in of patients had nailing of such a fracture in the series reported by et al. et al. that of the cases had of displacement at the fracture and were by of after intramedullary fixation of tibial fractures is a of of these fractures, which from to the that are commonly used to tibial nailing The that after the nailing of tibial fractures valgus in the deformity in the and posterior at the fracture The for these are simple to and in many cases can be by deformity and from a between the of the in the and the anatomic of the distal that the of the is caused by of a that is too and is caused to some degree by the of the of the tibial nailing is a is and the is to the this is the to the of the tibial the of the is much on the than is on the and the of the the Finally, the fracture that is most seen in the of the in the of the of the and and Therefore, there is no to help the and the the the distal valgus of the between the and the tibial the of the of the anterior compartment as a on the tibial which to valgus if of the fracture the nailing and the of a on the and displacement of a tibial fracture. and that a minimal and displacement of a tibial fracture. is the as that seen in and and A tibial fracture with valgus angulation. There was valgus deformity after nailing a deformity is to the of the an and of the and of the with the knee The of the the of the to anterior and posterior the fracture is to the in the can to with the distal In the the must be at the of the is anterior to the of the the must be to the The to the knee of the of the to of the of the at the fracture of the and of the are several to the of of tibial fractures The most is that the of the be as with the of the as is by of a high on the at the of the and the the in the and as as to the of the in the this has been to the within the The radiographic that to the have been described and have the of the tibial to the of the knee et al. reported that the for is mm to the of the and 3 mm to the of the tibial The of the mm and was as as mm in their In a and that the for the of a of is mm to the or mm to the of the tibial of these and a anterior to the of the the and that a with a knee be in the of the on the and the to be after which the can be used to the of the knee from the and In to prevent the tibial from the must be as in the as The for anterior and and the used for tibial and of the on and with Tibial the radiographic of the anatomic to the of of tibial fractures is the of as by et al. and by which is simple to involves the of the to of the The to the in the tibial and have been to the of the fractures are commonly from distal and anterior to and used in fractures are not as they are in midshaft fractures. The as a posterior the to the anterior as is in a midshaft fracture. the is in the posterior of the of the in the the from and the and an in the region for the the at and prevent valgus from the tibial should be used for the and they be in after the is that are to should be used for et al. reported the of the of for consecutive fractures of the of the patients had of for had a valgus deformity, and a had not been used in that et al. reported on fractures for which they had used an to decide if were to reduction nailing In the they make a of the with the knee in the fracture anterior they a posterior a is are are that have been to prevent of the of the reduction and fixation of the fracture with or a The most fractures fixation fixation is for the treatment of fractures in the region at or to the tibial or for fractures with of the nailing can be performed the fracture the is and must be by reduction and fixation of the fracture and after intramedullary nailing with of a and a tibial and tibial shaft for the to nailing of tibial fractures Tibial Fractures The of distal tibial fractures with intramedullary has had clinical than has nailing of fractures of the of the et al. reported on fractures of the distal tibial treated with a of the fractures had had and were of the patients nailing with distal after fixation of the with a patients had of to fracture nailing was was in patients in a mean of patients in and in in with a and deep infection in two patients had had an open fracture. In et al. reported on fractures of which had treated with a that they by the distal of the the These were after of the and with The was not in of the of the fractures and of the patients to is a distal tibial fractures are treated with intramedullary nailing of the distal the of to be is to evaluate alignment were in the series reported on by et al. or et al. the used by of these groups of included fixation of the et al. reported that of the cases in their series had varus or valgus of those authors not the with a fixation to have no on the of et al. described the of a to help the reduction of distal fractures nailing is performed on a fracture the is to the and nailing, then the fracture not have a deformity in the et al. reported on distal tibial fractures treated with an intramedullary were used in of these and were used in A was used for open fractures. A fracture was used for the treatment of these fractures. fractures were with of and had displacement of an fracture. et al. that, for distal fractures that has a high of of and they nailing On the basis of experience and the information available in the literature, that distal tibial fractures with minimal of the can be treated with intramedullary is performed with the a fracture is not the of an surgeon or of a is useful to help reduction of the distal is by that have distal and that have to the of the is not to the that a simple if of the is not available with two or within of the of the are for distal fractures. fixation not to be to and fixation to the fracture is fixation of the to nailing of the is a useful for the of fixation is if there is of the associated with a distal fracture. there is not information with which to determine the of fracture is simple to a fracture that to the fractures are with The most in avoiding of the distal is that the is in the of the and that is to the A useful for that the is is that described by et al. in which a is the distal and to the this as a is simple to the alignment of the as is to the the should to the at a The can as a with which to the distal and after of a distal tibial fracture, with a to with There are many after intramedullary these anterior knee delayed or nonunion, is to delayed and to are the most to consider of fracture factors are associated with an of delayed or following intramedullary These factors of a severe soft-tissue injury open or bone and The for the of be as was in a that cause a of to that seen with of has been in several early clinical to be associated with a time to weight-bearing, return to work, and be to the that less fracture than do to a lead to or clinical studies of nailing have much of and to comparative clinical studies have that the of and tibial nailing are authors have described to the of delayed after the treatment of a tibial fracture with a et al. used at and weeks to determine the of and they if of was not seen by weeks of the by weeks after the nailing was predictive of of the et al. early at and they reported that this the time to from thirty-seven weeks to weeks soft-tissue injury and bone are factors that the surgeon that have with regard to These two factors are for the of severe tibial fractures. for the treatment of tibial fractures with soft-tissue injury bone of soft-tissue and bone and early soft-tissue by delayed is as that is associated with delayed of fractures should be regarding the of and more treatment should be considered for patients is to with is usually the of a less infection should be considered in patients with delayed or and should be and is if they are should be performed a is for the treatment of a et al. reported that of patients with an infection at the of a were treated with of the and of a intramedullary The of infection associated with and with be than that associated with with or can the of problems. is most that nailing be used fracture and and nailing be used for open and closed fractures treated with nailing should have nailing, or only if there is of delayed after to of tibial nailing can cause disability and is common following fractures of the of the deformity of midshaft fractures, fractures, can if an is Finally, reduction can be following in fractures of the distal of the after nailing of tibial shaft fractures can usually be by to the of the operative including to determine the and of the must be of to determine the length must be the is fractures of the of the are treated with nailing, more complex such as the of are appropriate knee is an cause of disability after tibial nailing is to be more common are used a study that knee was common of whether a or had been et al. reported knee after tibial nailing in of their patients and et al. in of is more common in Although is can and and to of patients have knee at The after of the in of patients and in Tibial nailing a or a to et al. the of the to the anterior and the to these to knee et al. reported the for to be mm to the of the and 3 mm to the of the tibial The of the mm and was as as mm in their of or the is most common are with a reported as high as are associated with an of delayed and have less of which lead to an of To the of a should be used with two distal than et al. reported that the of was a distal had been used with two had been used Indications are for of the soft-tissue of the fixation has been associated with an high of has been performed for more severe open fractures fixation of tibial shaft fractures is most the fracture pattern is simple, whereas in of patients in a fracture is treated with fixation The of lead to a of fixation of long-bone fractures. the of fixation for the treatment of tibial shaft fractures is fixation is a good for the of tibial fixation is the are such as in with an open fracture or a high-energy closed fracture. of the fracture and a fracture in a with are to A be to the or of the is less likely to result in soft-tissue and be the as a if the fracture is a is a this a is with the fracture and the of the and after internal fixation with a a of a tibial and are the associated with fixation The of these can be soft-tissue is performed at the time of the In the of the high of and of associated with as other have good with less of Indications fixation is a that can be used for fracture. is for of two fixation or fixation is the initial treatment of for high-energy closed or open fractures the of the is In these be to the degree of soft-tissue injury to a final or fixation is fixation is usually for patients with and or patients with a complex fracture. In the a or is and and after reduction of a fracture in a with of an for are no to the of fixation for the treatment of closed tibial shaft fractures. fixation of tibial shaft fractures is with a to the of the The should be in to problems. The skin should be to to are with two on of the fracture. is the fracture with of the fracture and the is some The of the is by two and the to the The system be by by the from the on the of the be to the fracture the is and infection are the problems. in if fixation with an intramedullary or is the of an the of authors have an of infection nailing was performed following more than two weeks of fixation Most authors have that the be and be to of an intramedullary that and of and of is a to the of infection intramedullary fixation is to be after of an In patients with a closed, tibial fracture can be treated with a nailing is more and studies with to be to Operative treatment is for open or closed fractures and for fractures that be in fixation is the treatment of for the of tibial fractures that
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Schmidt et al. (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: