Key result
Etomidate prolonged motor seizure duration compared to propofol but resulted in higher mean blood pressure and heart rate during and immediately after electroconvulsive therapy.
Why the study?
Previous studies comparing the hemodynamic effects of propofol and etomidate during electroconvulsive therapy yielded ambiguous results and were limited by small sample sizes or retrospective designs.
Does etomidate compared to propofol affect hemodynamics and motor seizure duration in patients undergoing modified electroconvulsive therapy?
RCT (n=30)
Double-blind
Computer random number generator with random permuted blocks
No
Does etomidate compared to propofol affect hemodynamics and motor seizure duration in patients undergoing modified electroconvulsive therapy?
While propofol provides better hemodynamic stability during electroconvulsive therapy, etomidate significantly prolongs motor seizure duration, potentially enhancing therapeutic efficacy.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Propofol offers superior hemodynamic stability in ECT; extends RCT evidence on anesthetic trade-offs with seizure duration.
Background and Aims: Studies comparing the effect of propofol and etomidate on hemodynamic parameters during electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) have shown ambiguous results. Although some studies observed a larger increase in blood pressure and heart rate during the use of etomidate than propofol in ECT, whereas some studies have shown no difference in hemodynamic parameters with the use of etomidate or propofol. Most of the studies done to compare the hemodynamic effects of etomidate and propofol were limited by small sample size or retrospective in nature. Therefore, we conducted a prospective randomized trial to compare the effects of etomidate and propofol on hemodynamics during ECT. Material and Methods: A prospective randomized crossover study was conducted on 30 patients with American Society of Anesthesiologist physical status I and II, between age 18 and 65 years, suffering from a mental disorder as per International Classification of Diseases-10 and requiring bilateral ECT as per clinical decision of consultant psychiatrist. They were randomized to receive both the drugs for their successive ECT sessions and were subjected to evaluation after clubbing together the ECT sessions of propofol or etomidate as anesthetic agent. Results: Duration of motor seizures was significantly more in patients receiving etomidate, whereas patients receiving propofol had more stable hemodynamics. Conclusion: Though propofol maintains stable hemodynamics during MECT, yet clinical applicability of etomidate outstrips it by a reasonable margin due to its better effect on seizure parameters.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mehta et al. (2022) conducted an RCT in Mental disorders requiring bilateral electroconvulsive therapy (n=30). Etomidate vs. Propofol (1 mg/kg IV) was evaluated on Motor seizure duration (seconds) (p=0.009). Etomidate prolonged motor seizure duration compared to propofol but resulted in higher mean blood pressure and heart rate during and immediately after electroconvulsive therapy.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: