Key result
Multiplex RT-PCR demonstrated the highest overall sensitivity for detecting influenza virus compared to enzyme immunoassay and virus isolation in community-based sampling.
Why the study?
Does RT-PCR improve the early detection of influenza epidemics compared to virus isolation and EIA in community-based surveillance?
Observational (n=1,685)
Yes
Does RT-PCR improve the early detection of influenza epidemics compared to virus isolation and EIA in community-based surveillance?
RT-PCR provides a rapid, sensitive, and specific method for early detection of influenza viruses in community-based surveillance systems, outperforming traditional virus isolation and EIA.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports RT-PCR for sensitive community influenza detection; leaves open its role in advancing epidemic surveillance over EIA or isolation.
Linking continuous community-based morbidity recording of influenza-like illness (ILI) with virological sampling has consistently proved its value as one of the earliest indicators of circulating influenza activity. The clinical morbidity recording in the Portuguese national surveillance network, during a 7-year period, and the contribution of different diagnostic techniques, including virus isolation, multiplex RT-PCR, immunocapture enzyme linked immunoassay (EIA) and complement fixation tests (CFTs) for the detection of influenza in such a community-based setting is described and evaluated in this study. There was good correlation between the increase of morbidity, total samples taken and the detection of influenza virus by all the methods although this was less evident for virus isolation and EIA than for RT-PCR or serology. From a total of 1685 throat swabs collected from cases of ILI, 43.6% were RT-PCR positive, 17.5% were positive by capture EIA and in 5% virus isolates were made. The detection of influenza by RT-PCR occurred earlier than by any other method and showed the best correlation with epidemic patterns of morbidity registration. We conclude that in surveillance systems where virus culture is sub-optimal, RT-PCR provides a rapid, sensitive, specific method for detecting influenza viruses from community-based sampling.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rebelo‐de‐Andrade et al. (2000) conducted an observational in Influenza-like illness (ILI) (n=1,685). Multiplex RT-PCR vs. Immunocapture EIA and virus isolation was evaluated on Overall sensitivity for detecting influenza virus (using positive result by any test as the gold standard). Multiplex RT-PCR demonstrated the highest overall sensitivity for detecting influenza virus compared to enzyme immunoassay and virus isolation in community-based sampling.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: