Key result
Nalbuphine resulted in a 7.24% mean drop in heart rate 3 minutes post-medication compared to 4.61% for fentanyl and 4.3% for butorphanol, though the difference was not significant.
Why the study?
Several techniques have been tried to attenuate adverse hemodynamic stress responses to intubation, prompting a comparison of fentanyl, nalbuphine, and butorphanol.
Does IV Nalbuphine or Butorphanol improve the attenuation of hemodynamic stress response during intubation compared to Fentanyl in female patients undergoing elective modified radical mastectomy?
RCT (n=90)
Simple computer generated randomization
No
Does IV Nalbuphine or Butorphanol improve the attenuation of hemodynamic stress response during intubation compared to Fentanyl in female patients undergoing elective modified radical mastectomy?
Nalbuphine, butorphanol, and fentanyl all effectively control hemodynamic stress during intubation, with nalbuphine showing the most favorable profile for preventing tachycardia.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May blunt intubation responses in mastectomy; leaves open optimal technique pending higher-level trials.
Several techniques have been tried in an effort to attenuate adverse hemodynamic stress responses to intubation. Commonly used techniques include increasing the depth of anesthesia by heavy premedication, inhalational anesthetic agents, intravenous (IV) and topical lignocaine, clonidine and dexmedotomidine, calcium channel blockers, sodium nitroprusside, beta-adrenergic blockers, and magnesium sulfate. Ninety female patients of 18-65 years of age, undergoing elective modified radical mastectomy (MRM) surgery for carcinoma breast at Kidwai Memorial Institute of Oncology, Bangalore were selected randomly. The study was conducted in the Department of Anesthesia and pain relief, Kidwai Memorial Institute of Oncology, Bangalore during the period from December 2018 to December 2019. So, in terms of Heart rate control during intubation and steady state of anaesthesia all three opioids showed efficacious control but Nalbuphine proved to be best as it prevented tachycardia during intubation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mukherjee et al. (2021) conducted an RCT in Carcinoma breast (n=90). Nalbuphine vs. Fentanyl (2 µg/kg IV) and Butorphanol (20 µg/kg IV) was evaluated on Mean drop in heart rate 3 minutes after medication compared to baseline (p=0.213). Nalbuphine resulted in a 7.24% mean drop in heart rate 3 minutes post-medication compared to 4.61% for fentanyl and 4.3% for butorphanol, though the difference was not significant.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: