Key result
Epidural analgesia compared to systemic morphine for splanchnic perfusion had a 44% overall complication rate, with methodological flaws precluding valid conclusions about efficacy.
Why the study?
Does epidural bupivacaine affect splanchnic blood flow compared to systemic morphine in surgical patients?
Does epidural bupivacaine affect splanchnic blood flow compared to systemic morphine in surgical patients?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This letter highlights significant methodological flaws in a prior study, suggesting its conclusions regarding epidural anesthesia and splanchnic blood flow are invalid.
Several points in the recent article about the effect of epidural bupivacaine on splanchnic blood flow (Mallinder et al. Anaesthesia 2000; 55: 659–65) are worth highlighting. The initial power calculation estimated that 40 patients would be required but only 32 were analysed. All the patients lost from the study were from the epidural group (12 vs. 20) making comparisons difficult. There were also many more patients who were ASA 3 in the morphine group than in the epidural group (8 vs. 2). I note that 44% of the total group suffered complications, ranging from wound infection to death, which seems excessively high. The authors acknowledged that it was possible that the epidural catheters were sited too low to achieve adequate sympathetic blockade, but countered this by suggesting that the large volumes of local anaesthetic used and the fact that patients were all comfortable postoperatively indicated an adequate dermatomal level of analgesia. The solution used in the study has not been validated to produce sympathetic blockade to T5 with a lumbar epidural catheter [1]. Patients would only require a dermatomal analgesia level of T8 to be comfortable intra- and postoperatively, far below the level required for sympathetic blockade of the mesenteric vessels [2]. At no point in the paper did they discuss blood pressure changes or the amount or type of intravenous fluid used to correct hypotension. It is well documented that epidural-induced hypotension can cause gut hypoperfusion [3]. If an adequate sympathetic blockade to T5 was achieved with the initial bolus, especially in this group of surgical patients, some degree of hypotension must have occurred. It would seem unlikely, given the combination of the above factors, that conclusions can be drawn about the effects of epidural analgesia as compared to systemic morphine on splanchnic perfusion.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
J. Low (2000) conducted a letter in Surgical patients (n=32). Epidural analgesia (bupivacaine) vs. Systemic morphine was evaluated on Splanchnic blood flow / perfusion. Epidural analgesia compared to systemic morphine for splanchnic perfusion had a 44% overall complication rate, with methodological flaws precluding valid conclusions about efficacy.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: