Key result
General anaesthesia caused a >30% rise in arterial pressure in 53.3% of patients, compared to 6.7% with spinal and 0% with epidural anaesthesia during lower extremity surgery with thigh tourniquet.
Why the study?
Does epidural or spinal anaesthesia compared to general anaesthesia improve haemodynamic stability during thigh tourniquet use in orthopaedic surgery?
RCT (n=51)
randomly divided
Does epidural or spinal anaesthesia compared to general anaesthesia improve haemodynamic stability during thigh tourniquet use in orthopaedic surgery?
Regional anaesthesia (spinal or epidural) provides better haemodynamic stability than general anaesthesia during prolonged thigh tourniquet use, though epidural anaesthesia may frequently require supplemental analgesia.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Regional anaesthesia preferred over general to avoid hypertensive surges with thigh tourniquet; confirms haemodynamic superiority in this RCT.
Haemodynamic changes were studied in 51 patients undergoing orthopaedic surgery of the lower extremity, including exsanguination and thigh tourniquet for longer than 60 min. The patients were randomly divided into three anaesthesia groups: general anaesthesia (including enflurane), epidural anaesthesia (20 ml 0.5% bupivacaine) and spinal anaesthesia (3 ml 0.5% bupivacaine). During the study, five epidural and one spinal patient excluded from haemodynamic comparison required general anaesthesia because of pain from the surgery or ischaemia. In the general anaesthesia group, there was a rise in either systolic or diastolic arterial pressure of over 30% of the control value in 8/15 patients. In the spinal anaesthesia patients, there was a transient rise above 30% in only one patient out of 15 and no rise in the 15 epidural group patients. On the other hand, 11/15 of the epidural patients needed additional analgesics and/or sedation for pain or restlessness. The mean rise in the haemodynamic parameters including CVP was small on inflation of the tourniquet cuff; on deflation there was a mean decrease in CVP of 1-3 cmH2 (0.1-0.3 kPa), the maximum decrease being 8 cmH2O (0.8 kPa). The mean decrease in systolic arterial blood pressure ranged from 2 to 14 mmHg (0.27 to 1.87 kPa) when the cuff was deflated.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Valli et al. (1985) conducted an RCT in Orthopaedic surgery of the lower extremity (n=51). General, epidural, or spinal anaesthesia vs. Active comparators (three-arm trial) was evaluated on Rise in either systolic or diastolic arterial pressure of over 30% of the control value. General anaesthesia caused a >30% rise in arterial pressure in 53.3% of patients, compared to 6.7% with spinal and 0% with epidural anaesthesia during lower extremity surgery with thigh tourniquet.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: