Key result
This letter to the editor argues that the association between step count and blood pressure dipping should be analyzed using systolic and diastolic profiles rather than mean blood pressure.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This letter to the editor critiques a study on step count and blood pressure dipping, highlighting methodological concerns regarding dipping classification, secondary hypertension prevalence, and ABPM use for diagnosis.
To the Editor: We read with great interest the article “Step Count Is Associated With Lower Nighttime Systolic Blood Pressure and Increased Dipping”1 by Wuerzner et al., which reported that step count is continuously associated with nighttime systolic blood pressure (BP) and with the degree of BP dipping independent of 24-hour mean BP. Nighttime BP dipping is a well-established cardiovascular (CV) risk factor in both nonhypertensive and hypertensive patients. The study performed by Wuerzner et al. is one of the few investigations focusing on the relationship between nighttime BP dipping and physical activity. One of the main advantages of this study was to determine the daytime and nighttime periods using recordings of the actigraph, which allowed the precise nighttime BP dipping estimation for each participant. However, for the dipping estimation, the authors used different classification: relative nighttime systolic and diastolic pressure drop was calculated separately as (1 − nighttime BP/daytime BP) × 100%, but dipping profiles were assessed as mean BP (MBP = BP + 1/3 of pulse pressure) drop, which was calculated as (1 − nighttime MBP/daytime MBP) × 100%. In this article, step count (as a physical activity parameter) was analyzed only in MBP extreme dippers, dippers, nondippers and reverse dippers (not in systolic and diastolic dipping BP profiles), whereas the relative systolic and diastolic nighttime BP drop was assessed in physical activity categories of patients. Data from large prospective studies have confirmed that systolic dippers have lower CV risk than systolic nondippers and reverse dippers. This is not evident for MBP dippers. An analysis of step count in systolic and diastolic BP dipping profiles would be more valuable because it would allow influence of physical activity to be shown on these profiles. There are several additional concerns about the study of Wuerzner et al. Young patients were included, and it is known that the general prevalence of secondary hypertension in this group is higher than other age groups and CV risk is different than in primary hypertension; thus the prevalence of participants with secondary hypertension is needed, especially in the context of the conclusion of the study. The authors also diagnosed hypertension using daytime or nighttime BP values recorded by an ambulatory blood pressure monitoring (ABPM) device. But ABPM is not recommended by the European Society of Hypertension guidelines for the diagnosis of hypertension.2 Moreover, the large meta-analysis of 20 studies performed by Hodgkinson et al. revealed that there is a significant difference in the diagnosis of hypertension based on ABPM and clinical measurements.3 Although the authors showed that antihypertensive drugs did not influence BP dipping, there was no information about groups of medications and the period of the day in which the drugs were taken. The randomized study performed on 2,156 individuals by Portaluppi et al. confirmed that the time in which antihypertensive drugs are taken is essential in nighttime BP dipping.4 We are convinced that instead of novelty results of the study additional information that we regard as relevant would add further data in dipping profile assessment according to ABPM and physical activity. The authors declared no conflict of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sobiczewski et al. (2013) conducted a letter in Hypertension. Step count was evaluated. This letter to the editor argues that the association between step count and blood pressure dipping should be analyzed using systolic and diastolic profiles rather than mean blood pressure.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: