Key result
Stentless porcine xenograft aortic root replacement showed equivalent 10-year survival compared to a mechanical composite prosthesis in quinquagenarians.
Why the study?
Does stentless porcine xenoroot replacement provide equivalent long-term survival compared to mechanical composite prosthesis in quinquagenarians undergoing aortic root replacement?
Cohort (n=205)
Does stentless porcine xenoroot replacement provide equivalent long-term survival compared to mechanical composite prosthesis in quinquagenarians undergoing aortic root replacement?
In patients aged 50-60 years, stentless porcine xenograft aortic root replacement offers equivalent long-term survival to a mechanical Bentall procedure, challenging the routine use of mechanical conduits in this age group.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May support stentless xenografts as alternative in quinquagenarians; leaves open need for randomized confirmation of equivalence.
BACKGROUND: The choice of the best conduit for root/ascending disease and its impact on longevity remain controversial in quinquagenarians. METHODS AND RESULTS: A total of 205 patients (men=155) between 50 and 60 years (mean, 55.7 ± 2.9 years) received either a stentless porcine xenoroot (n=78) or a mechanically valved composite prosthesis (n=127) between February 1998 and July 2011. Of these, 166 patients underwent root replacement for aneurysmal disease (porcine: 39% [n=65]; mechanical: 61% [n=101]; P=0.5), 25 for acute type A aortic dissection (porcine: 32% [n=8]; mechanical: 68% [n=17]; P=0.51), and 14 for endocarditis/iatrogenic injury involving the aortic root (6.4% [n=5] versus 7.1% [n=9]; P=1.0). The predominant aortic valve pathology was stenosis in 19% (n=38), regurgitation in 50% (n=102), combined valvular dysfunction in 26% (n=54), and normal aortic valve function in 5% (n=11). Concomitant procedures included coronary artery bypass grafting (13%), mitral valve repair (7%), and partial/complete arch replacement (12%/4%), with no significant differences between porcine and mechanical root replacement. Overall hospital mortality was 7.3%, with no difference between the 2 types of valve prostheses (7.7% for porcine and 7.1% for mechanical root replacement; P=1.0). Follow-up averaged 5.4 ± 3.7 years (1096 patient-years) and was 100% complete. Freedom from aorta-related reoperation at 12 years was not statistically different between the groups (porcine: 94.9% versus mechanical: 96.1%; P=0.73). Survival was equivalent between both groups, with a 5-year survival of 86 ± 3% (porcine: 88 ± 4%; mechanical: 85 ± 3%; P=0.96) and a 10-year survival of 76% (porcine: 80 ± 7%; mechanical: 75 ± 5%; P=0.84). The linearized mortality rate was 3.1%/patient-year (porcine: 2.9%/patient-year; mechanical: 3.2%/patient-year). CONCLUSIONS: In quinquagenerians, long-term survival after stentless porcine xenograft aortic root replacement is equivalent to that after a mechanical Bentall procedure. These results bring into question the predominance of mechanical composite conduits for root replacement in quinquagenerians, particularly in the current era of transcatheter valve-in-valve procedures for structural valve deterioration.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Etz et al. (2013) conducted a cohort in Aortic root/ascending disease (n=205). Stentless porcine xenoroot vs. Mechanically valved composite prosthesis was evaluated on 10-year survival (p=0.84). Stentless porcine xenograft aortic root replacement showed equivalent 10-year survival compared to a mechanical composite prosthesis in quinquagenarians.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: