Why the study?
Does simultaneous blood pressure measurement in both arms reveal clinically significant inter-arm differences in adults?
Does simultaneous blood pressure measurement in both arms reveal clinically significant inter-arm differences in adults?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Simultaneous measurement of blood pressure in both arms reveals clinically significant differences in 20% of patients, providing a strong rationale for bilateral measurement at the first consultation.
It is normally recommended that a patient's blood pressure is measured in both arms on the first consultation [1,2]. I usually take measurements from one arm and then the other, and teach students to do the same. Occasionally, I am asked for the reasons behind this practice and respond by explaining that there are sometimes important differences between the two readings, and that the lower blood pressure in one arm should be investigated further in such cases because it may stem from an abnormality (coarctation, stenosis, dissection, etc.) which requires further exploration. I am aware that this response is rather vague and that the practice of measuring blood pressure in both arms is not widespread, and is even omitted in certain recommendations for the management of high blood pressure [3]. In their last recommendations, the World Health Organization and International Society of Hypertension proposed measuring blood pressure in both arms on the first consultation if there is evidence of peripheral vascular disease [4]. Along with others, I have been made aware of the need to measure from both arms due to the increasing use of ambulatory blood pressure monitors. The arm-bands of these devices are normally placed on the non-dominant arm for the convenience of the patient. On placing of the armband, it is clearly important to measure blood pressure from the controlateral arm simultaneously with the first measurement of the device to check that the device is operating correctly. This often makes it evident that the main reason for the difference in readings between the two arms is that they are not recorded simultaneously. In this situation, apart from the inherent variability in the measurements and in blood pressure itself, there is a lessening of the ‘white-coat’ effect, which usually makes the second reading lower than the first. It could be that a systematic difference between the two arms has more theoretical than practical consequences and is small compared to the variability of the measurement. In this issue of the journal, Lane and Beevers [5] demonstrate that the old practice of measuring blood pressure from both arms is justified and should be encouraged. Their study is simple, but their methodology is rigorous. To find out whether there is a systematic difference the following procedures are required: (i) simultaneous measurement from both arms; (ii) automatic method of measurement due to the many biases in observer readings; (iii) a large number of measurements to be able to identify a small but statistically significant difference; and (iv) a sufficiently large and varied population to have a reliable estimate of the phenomenon and to seek factors that might be linked to it. This study appears to be the first to fulfil all these conditions and was conducted on 200 men and 200 women, aged 18–92 years, of whom 20% had high blood pressure and 15% were diabetic. Two validated automatic Omron HEM-705CP devices, numbered 1 and 2, were employed to ensure that two simultaneous pairs of measurements were taken for each patient, with swapping of the devices between series to avoid machine bias and to reduce any variability inherent in the equipment. The relative and absolute differences in values of blood pressure measured from the right and left arms have different implications. The authors found that the blood pressure was, on average, 1.8 mmHg higher when measured from the right than from the left arms with a standard deviation of 8 mmHg. There is no obvious explanation for this difference, although the first possibility that comes to mind is that the right arm is generally the dominant one. It is subjected to the most activity and thus has a more developed musculature. However, this study only included 10% of left-handed individuals and could not assess whether lateral dominance was the main factor for the difference between right and left arms. The authors did find that blood pressure was higher in the right arm in the 361 right-handed subjects with no significance difference between the two arms in the 39 left-handed subjects. The circumference of the arm did not appear to be involved, but it may not have been measured with enough accuracy to demonstrate any difference between the dominant and non-dominant arm. Explanations based on anatomical differences in the right and left arterial systems are unconvincing. The tendency for a higher pressure measured in the right arm may contribute to the difference between office blood pressure, which is generally measured on the right arm, and the self measured or ambulatory values, which are generally measured on the left arm. Of greater significance is the absolute difference in value between the two arms: on average, this was 6 mmHg for the systolic and 5 mmHg for the diastolic blood pressure. The difference appeared to be of clinical significance in 20% of patients with a difference in systolic blood pressure exceeding 10 mmHg, and in 3% of patients the difference was greater than 20 mmHg. Age appeared to be the only parameter significantly linked to the magnitude of this difference. It is not impossible that the 3% of patients with a difference of more than 20 mmHg between arms had unrecognized arterial disease. In practice, a difference of this magnitude between the two arms, verified by a simultaneous measurement, should prompt investigation of a local cause. The results of this simple, but rigorous clinical study provide a rationale for continuation or resumption of the older practice of measuring blood pressure from both arms. We should carry out a bilateral measurement on first consultation in all our patients and, in the event of a significant difference, we should check the measurements by a simultaneous measurement. In 20% of our patients, the differences observed will have implications for the ultimate diagnosis of hypertension and its follow-up, especially in those included in a therapeutic trial. These recommendations, which are now backed-up by data from a careful study, need to be disseminated and included in the guidelines for the measurement of blood pressure, particularly in view of their educational role [6].
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Philippe Gosse (2002) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: