Key result
Sequential or manual blood pressure measurements result in an approximate twofold increase in the relative risk of detecting a 10 mm Hg systolic inter-arm difference compared to simultaneous automated methods.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The author proposes a practical approach to inter-arm blood pressure measurement, starting with sequential assessment and reserving simultaneous automated measurement for confirming discrepancies.
Blood pressure guidelines advise the measurement of blood pressure in both arms at initial assessment. Detection of an inter-arm difference in blood pressure is important for three reasons: First, failure to identify a difference can delay the diagnosis of hypertension. Second, if the lower reading arm is used in the presence of an unrecognized difference this can lead to undertreatment, therapeutic inertia, or even inappropriate reduction in therapy (pseudohypotension). Third and most significant, there is a growing body of evidence from cross sectional and prospective cohort studies that a systolic inter-arm difference is a sign of peripheral vascular disease and is independently associated with increased mortality (Figure 1, next page).1 A systolic inter-arm difference ≥15 mm Hg has come to be termed “subclavian stenosis ” by authors although direct radiological evidence of proximal upper limb vascular disease in the general population with such differences is lacking,2 and guidelines now attribute inter-arm differences to peripheral vascular disease although this is based on consensus rather than published evidence.3 No published guidelines suggest how to best measure an inter-arm difference, therefore the systematic review of Verberk, Kessels and Thien4 is an useful addition to the literature. They find consistent relative risks suggesting an approximate twofold increase in prevalence of a 10 mm Hg systolic inter-arm difference if the diagnosis is based either on a single pair of measurements, uses a sequential approach, or manual rather than automated measurements. Thus half of all subjects identified without the use of a “gold standard ” repeated simultaneous automated method will not actually possess an inter-arm difference of this magnitude on repeated assessment. The discrepancies are higher when diastolic or larger systolic cut offs are examined. Their conclusion that a simultaneous measurement technique collecting at least two pairs of measurements is needed agrees with previous studies and reviews, but putting this into practice as an initial assessment would require investment in automated equipment and clinical time. Bilateral blood pressure measurement has not yet been adopted by the majority of practitioners, consequently this new evidence will mainly interest researchers in the field, and only a repeated simultaneous automated measurement technique should be employed for future studies. For routine care I would argue that initially a simpler approach is needed if bilateral arm measurement is to be taken up as guidelines suggest. That is why we favor starting with a simple sequential assessment making one pair of measurements at first examination. This has a high specificity and can rule out true inter-arm difference at one sitting in 80–90% of the population.5 It leaves a much smaller proportion of patients, with a difference at the first examination, requiring assessment with automated simultaneous bilateral arm measurements to confirm their inter-arm difference. Such selected patients should be assessed with the gold standard approach identified by this review, since decisions on aggressive primary prevention treatments with antiplatelet agents and statins and lifestyle interventions are likely to be made on the basis of their inter-arm difference, in the absence of other recognized cardiovascular risk factors. The authors declared no conflict of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Christopher E Clark (2011) conducted an editorial in Inter-arm blood pressure difference. Sequential or manual blood pressure measurement vs. Simultaneous automated measurement was evaluated on Prevalence of a 10 mm Hg systolic inter-arm difference. Sequential or manual blood pressure measurements result in an approximate twofold increase in the relative risk of detecting a 10 mm Hg systolic inter-arm difference compared to simultaneous automated methods.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: