Key result
Aortic valvotomy in a 25-year-old woman with rheumatic heart disease unmasked severe tricuspid stenosis, which accounted for her unexpected failure to improve post-operatively.
Case Report (n=1)
Aortic valvotomy in a patient with rheumatic heart disease can unmask previously unrecognized severe tricuspid stenosis, explaining a lack of symptomatic improvement.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May warrant tricuspid evaluation in rheumatic patients with unexpected post-valvotomy symptoms; leaves open need for systematic multivalvular assessment.
Surgical treatment of a rheumatic valvular lesion may exaggerate the physical signs or lead to the recognition for the first time of another valvular lesion.This is seen in combined lesions of the aortic and mitral valves and less frequently of the mitral and tricuspid valve.Tricuspid stenosis (Pantridge and Marshall, 1957) and tricuspid incompetence (Mounsey, 1959) have been revealed after mitral valvotomy but not after aortic valvotomy.This is probably due to the fact that rheu- matic tricuspid disease is nearly always associated with mitral disease, less commonly with mitral and aortic valve disease and rarely with aortic disease alone (Gibson and Wood, 1955; Goodwin et al., 1957; Killip and Lukas, 1958; Perloff and Harvey, 1960).The following case report is of a young patient in whom tricuspid stenosis was revealed after aortic valvotomy.The tricuspid lesion accounted for unexpected failure to improve after a technically successful aortic valvotomy but its surgical correction at a second operation led to marked clinical improvement.Case Report Elizabeth McL., aged 25, was first seen in April 1957.She had a history of tonsillectomy when 7 and of rheumatic fever and chorea when 8 years old.For about 2 years she had complained of increasing tiredness and breathlessness on exertion, palpitation and occasional precordial pain or giddiness on unaccustomed exercise.She could only climb 8 steps without having to pause for breath.She was a well nourished, healthy-looking young woman.Her arterial pulses were small and sustained and the heart rate 50 per minute.Examination of the heart, which was not clinically enlarged, suggested left ventricular hypertrophy and the dominant physical sign was a harsh basal systolic murmur widely conducted, felt as a thrill at the aortic area and accompanied by a soft aortic diastolic murmur.Venous pulsation was noted in the root of her neck to a height of about 1 cm.above the sternal angle but a tricuspid lesion was not suspected at this time.Her brachial arterial pressure was 130/100 mm.Hg.Radiological examination showed left ventri- cular enlargement and a prominent ascending aorta; there was no left atrial enlargement and no valvular calcification (Fig. 1).She was considered to have severe rheumatic aortic stenosis without significant incompetence and in view of her age and symptoms operation was advised.A transventricular aortic valvotomy was carried out on 7/6/57 with satisfactory splitting of the stenosed valve.The post-operative period was uneventful and her blood pressure was now about 120/75 mm.Hg.Her subsequent progress was disappointing, there being little or no symptomatic improvement and she complained bitterly of "being unable to get a move on."Soon after her operation she became aware of a new symptom-a fluttering sensation in her neck, and prominent pulsations were noticed there both by her- self and her relatives.When seen again in January 1958 these were obviously giant "a" waves and, on careful auscultation, a tricuspid pre-systolic murmur and opening snap were heard (Fig. 2A).Furthermore, serial X-rays showed that the right atrium had become prominent since her operation (Fig. 1) and examination of serial electrocardiograms showed that there had previously been evidence of right atrial hypertrophy.Cardiac catheterization on 2/5/60 confirmed the clinical diagnosis of severe tricuspid stenosis (Fig. 2B).There was a low resting cardiac output (2-8 litres per minute), normal pressures in the wedged pulmonary artery position (-1 5 mm.Hg mean), pulmonary artery (29/10 mm.Hg) and right ventricle (29/-4 mm.Hg) and raised right atrial pressure (22/0 mm.Hg) with giant "a" waves and an atrio-ventricular pressure gradient.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Watson et al. (1962) conducted a case report in Rheumatic aortic stenosis and tricuspid stenosis (n=1). Aortic valvotomy was evaluated. Aortic valvotomy in a 25-year-old woman with rheumatic heart disease unmasked severe tricuspid stenosis, which accounted for her unexpected failure to improve post-operatively.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: