Key result
Percutaneous coronary intervention for unstable coronary disease is reported in 82% of cases in the United States, compared to 65% in the United Kingdom and 59% in Ontario, Canada.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The article highlights the potential for 'upcoding' clinical information to classify stable angina as unstable in order to meet Appropriate Use Criteria for PCI in the United States.
reason to disregard ORBITA 1 in the United States, according to some key opinion leaders is the startlingly high proportion of percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) that is performed for unstable coronary disease in the United States by comparison to peers.In the United States, 82% of PCIs are reported to be performed in emergency or unstable situations 2 in comparison to approximately 65% in the United Kingdom 3 and, closer to home, 59% in the province of Ontario, Canada.4 In this article, we look for evidence of so-called "gaming" or "upcoding" in which coronary disease becomes rated as more acute.Appropriate use criteria (AUC) for coronary revascularization seek to inhibit unnecessary procedures, 5 but there are in fact 2 ways a physician can become compliant.One is to do fewer unnecessary procedures, and the other is to make unnecessary procedures seem necessary.This is much easier to do than many nonphysicians appreciate. INSTABILITY IS IN THE EYE OF THE BEHOLDERAUC make a sharp distinction between stable angina which arises predictably on exertion and unstable angina which is rapidly escalating in intensity or occurring at rest.In medical school, these seem to be easy to distinguish.On the one hand is a patient attending an outpatient clinic because of angina on walking up hills.On the other is a patient confined to the hospital bed because of episodes of rest pain, perhaps with dynamic ECG changes during the pain.We know the latter group stand to gain from early PCI.However, unlike many cardiological assessments we make, there is no diagnostic test to confirm or refute unstable angina.As a result, the clinician is free to judge whether a patient's angina is unstable or not. INFECTIOUS INSTABILITYPatients, too, have to make decisions, for example, whether sensations do indeed fall into the category of "pain."They already know that pain is more concerning in the chest than elsewhere.Seeing a cardiologist can have a transformative effect on the symptom experienced and its instability.This impact is at 3 levels: knowledge, attitude, and behavior.6 At the simple knowledge level, the doctor reassures the patient that medication is the key to preventing stable coronary disease from turning into a serious event.However, the explicitly verbalized facts are only a small part of what is communicated.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rajkumar et al. (2019) conducted an editorial in Unstable coronary disease. Percutaneous Coronary Intervention was evaluated. Percutaneous coronary intervention for unstable coronary disease is reported in 82% of cases in the United States, compared to 65% in the United Kingdom and 59% in Ontario, Canada.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: