Key result
The 3D geometrical model estimated a peak shear stress of 13.31 Pa at 80% stenosis compared to 10.09 Pa in the 2D model, indicating 3D models are more suitable for analyzing severe disease conditions.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
2D computational models may be sufficient for analyzing normal coronary blood flow, but 3D models are more suitable for accurately estimating shear stress under severe disease conditions.
Shear stress plays a pivotal role in pathogenesis of coronary heart disease. The spatial and temporal variation in hemodynamics of blood flow, especially shear stress, is dominated by the vessel geometry. The goal of the present study was to investigate the effect of 2D and 3D geometries on the numerical modeling of coronary blood flow and shear stress distribution. We developed physiologically realistic 2D and 3D models (with similar geometries) of the human left coronary artery under normal and stenosis conditions (30%, 60%, and 80%) using PROE (WF 3). Transient blood flows in these models were solved using laminar and turbulent (k-ω) models using a computational fluid dynamics solver, FLUENT (v6.3.26). As the stenosis severity increased, both models predicted a similar pattern of increased shear stress at the stenosis throat, and in recirculation zones formed downstream of the stenosis. The 2D model estimated a peak shear stress value of 0.91, 2.58, 5.21, and 10.09 Pa at the throat location under normal, 30%, 60%, and 80% stenosis severity. The peak shear stress values at the same location estimated by the 3D model were 1.41, 2.56, 3.15, and 13.31 Pa, respectively. The 2D model underestimated the shear stress distribution inside the recirculation zone compared with that of 3D model. The shear stress estimation between the models diverged as the stenosis severity increased. Hence, the 2D model could be sufficient for analyzing coronary blood flow under normal conditions, but under disease conditions (especially 80% stenosis) the 3D model was more suitable.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Shanmugavelayudam et al. (2010) studied Coronary heart disease. 3D geometrical model vs. 2D geometrical model was evaluated on Peak shear stress at the stenosis throat. The 3D geometrical model estimated a peak shear stress of 13.31 Pa at 80% stenosis compared to 10.09 Pa in the 2D model, indicating 3D models are more suitable for analyzing severe disease conditions.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: