Key result
This letter highlights discrepancies in the 2005 ESC guidelines for chronic heart failure regarding the recommendations for aldosterone receptor antagonists and angiotensin receptor blockers.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Highlights inconsistencies in the 2005 ESC heart failure guidelines regarding the specific indications and timing for aldosterone antagonists and ARBs.
The Task Force for the diagnosis and treatment of chronic heart failure (CHF) of the European Society of Cardiology are to be congratulated on a comprehensive, evidence-based, and practical guide to the contemporary management of this condition.1 However, some discrepancies exist between the document's text, figures, and tables that may lead to confusion. These discrepancies relate primarily to prescribing recommendations for pharmacological therapy. Specifically, aldosterone receptor antagonists are recommended in Figure 4 of the guidelines for patients in New York Heart Association (NYHA) functional class I or II who had post-myocardial infarction (MI). No specific time period post-MI is mentioned. Table 22 of the guidelines recommend aldosterone antagonists for these patients if there is a ‘recent MI’. However, the text states that ‘whether an aldosterone antagonist is of proven benefit in patients with class II heart failure or asymptomatic left ventricular (LV) dysfunction remains to be established’. To resolve these discrepancies, the text, figure, and table should be more definitive on what evidence actually exists for these recommendations. Specifically, the EPHESUS study2 randomized patients to eplerenone or placebo 3–14 days post-MI who had LV systolic dysfunction and either symptoms of heart failure or diabetes mellitus, finding significant clinical benefit with the aldosterone antagonist. Whether such benefit exists when treatment is initiated beyond 14 days post-MI or in patients with established CHF of any aetiology is uncertain and requires further investigation, specifically in NYHA class I and II patients (the benefits of aldosterone antagonism in class III and IV patients with established CHF having already been observed in the RALES study).3 Similarly, discrepancies exist with regard to recommendations for angiotensin receptor blockers (ARBs). Figure 4 recommends ARBs for NYHA class II patients only if they are angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitor-intolerant. However, the evidence-base supports the use of ARBs in addition to ACE-inhibitors in these patients to reduce hospitalizations and mortality, as explicitly stated in the text of the guidelines. In this case, appropriate summation of the evidence (from CHARM-Added4 and Val-HeFT5) is provided in the text, documented accurately and concisely in Table 22, yet not followed in the figure.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Henry Krum (2005) conducted a letter in chronic heart failure. This letter highlights discrepancies in the 2005 ESC guidelines for chronic heart failure regarding the recommendations for aldosterone receptor antagonists and angiotensin receptor blockers.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: