Key result
Modified constant infusion method overestimates standard inulin clearance by ~4.5 ml/min/1.73 m2, proving unsuitable.
Why the study?
Does the steady-state constant infusion method accurately measure inulin and PAH clearance compared to the standard bladder clearance method in patients with renal disease?
Observational (n=25)
Does the steady-state constant infusion method accurately measure inulin and PAH clearance compared to the standard bladder clearance method in patients with renal disease?
The steady-state constant infusion method is not suitable for accurate measurement of inulin and PAH clearance in patients with renal disease due to incomplete urinary recovery and circadian rhythms.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Clinicians should avoid modified constant infusion for precise GFR measurement in renal disease; cross-sectional data leaves open validation of alternatives.
We investigated the validity of the steady-state constant infusion method (CIM), in which quantitative urinary recovery and constant plasma concentrations of the solute infused are required. Successive 3-h clearances of inulin and p-aminohippuric acid (PAH) were determined for 27 h in 25 patients with renal disease. Results were compared with the standard method of bladder clearance (StM) and with a modified CIM (ModCIM). The 24-h urinary recovery was incomplete for both inulin and PAH. Mean 24-h ModCIM inulin clearance overestimated StM by 4.5 ml.min-1 x 1.73 m-2 (range 0-9, P < 0.001) independent of the extent of renal impairment and pointed to slow distribution and/or extrarenal clearance of inulin. For PAH, the difference between ModCIM and StM clearance was related to the average PAH clearance by ModCIM and StM (r = 0.78). Furthermore, neither plasma inulin nor PAH became completely constant, because of the circadian rhythm in renal function. In conclusion, the conditions of the steady-state CIM technique are not fulfilled, and the method is not suitable for accurate measurement of inulin and PAH clearance, especially when the clearance is low.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Acker et al. (1995) conducted an observational in renal disease (n=25). Modified constant infusion method (ModCIM) vs. Standard method of bladder clearance (StM) was evaluated on Inulin clearance (MD 4.5 ml.min-1 x 1.73 m-2, p=<0.001). The modified constant infusion method overestimated standard bladder clearance of inulin by a mean of 4.5 ml/min/1.73 m2, indicating it is unsuitable for accurate measurement.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: