Key result
Equilibrium rebreathing yields ~44% lower variation vs extrapolation for estimating mixed venous CO2 during exercise.
Why the study?
The accuracy and variability of the Defares extrapolation CO2 rebreathing method compared to the Collier equilibrium method for estimating mixed venous CO2 tension during exercise were uncertain.
Does the extrapolation (Defares) CO2 rebreathing method compare favorably to the equilibrium (Collier) method for estimating mixed venous CO2 tension in adult subjects during exercise?
Does the extrapolation (Defares) CO2 rebreathing method compare favorably to the equilibrium (Collier) method for estimating mixed venous CO2 tension in adult subjects during exercise?
The equilibrium (Collier) CO2 rebreathing method demonstrates lower variability than the extrapolation (Defares) method, making it superior for evaluating cardiac output during exercise.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports Collier method for lower variability in exercise CO2 estimates; leaves open validation against direct cardiac output measures.
A series of experiments was undertaken in a total of 95 adult subjects, of whom 25 had coronary artery disease, to evaluate the extrapolation (Defares) CO2 rebreathing method vs. the equilibrium (Collier) method for estimating mixed venous CO2 tension. Collier values were corrected for the downstream effect, whereas Defares values were uncorrected. Although the methods gave similar mean values in separate series with normal subjects walking on a treadmill set at 123 W for 3 min, Collier values had a coefficient of variation (CV) of 2.5% in duplicate determinations and Defares values had a CV of 4.5%. In paired comparisons Defares values averaged either higher or lower than Collier values depending on variations in technique and the analysis of Defares tracings. Collier values were essentially unaffected by the duration of the rebreathing period (10 vs. 15 s). The Collier technique appears to be superior for the exercise evaluation of cardiac output in healthy and diseased subjects when the goal is obtain values at 82 or 123 W in single test sessions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Auchincloss et al. (1980) studied Coronary artery disease and healthy subjects (n=95). Equilibrium (Collier) CO2 rebreathing method vs. Extrapolation (Defares) CO2 rebreathing method was evaluated on Coefficient of variation in duplicate determinations of mixed venous CO2 tension. The equilibrium (Collier) CO2 rebreathing method yielded a lower coefficient of variation than the extrapolation (Defares) method for estimating mixed venous CO2 tension during exercise.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: