Key result
MSCT rules out significant CAD with ~95% negative predictive value despite low sensitivity.
Why the study?
The accuracy of multislice cardiac computed tomography for detecting significant coronary artery disease in middle-aged symptomatic women was not well established.
Does multislice cardiac computed tomography (MSCT) accurately detect significant coronary artery disease compared to coronary arteriography in symptomatic middle-aged women with an abnormal exercise ECG?
Cross-Sectional (n=70)
Blinded
Does multislice cardiac computed tomography (MSCT) accurately detect significant coronary artery disease compared to coronary arteriography in symptomatic middle-aged women with an abnormal exercise ECG?
MSCT is highly accurate with an excellent negative predictive value for diagnosing significant CAD in symptomatic middle-aged women with abnormal stress tests.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
MSCT offers high NPV for ruling out significant CAD in symptomatic middle-aged women with abnormal stress tests; leaves open routine adoption pending larger prospective validation.
OBJECTIVE: To assess the accuracy of multislice cardiac computed tomography (MSCT) for detection of significant coronary artery disease (CAD) in middle-aged symptomatic women. METHODS: We included 70 women (51+/-8 years) with complaints of chest pain or dyspnea, and an abnormal maximum exercise electrocardiogram (ECG) (8.6+/-1.4 metabolic equivalents). All had a MSCT using a 16 detector rows scanner, and coronary arteriography (CA). Blinded results of the two modalities were compared using a segment, vessel, and patient-based analysis. RESULTS: On MSCT 36% had normal coronaries, 24% had significant CAD requiring revascularization, and the remainder had mild CAD. MSCT had reasonably high diagnostic accuracy at segment level (negative predictive value of 95%, positive predictive value 81%, specificity 99%, and sensitivity 50%), regarding single or multivessel CAD when both nonassessable and assessable segments were included in the analysis. The agreement between the segments comparing MSCT and CA for significant CAD was excellent at 98% (kappa value 0.89). CONCLUSIONS: In this cohort of middle-aged symptomatic women with an abnormal stress test, 24% had significant CAD requiring intervention. MSCT was highly accurate in diagnosing significant CAD with an excellent negative predictive value.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Shivalkar et al. (2007) conducted a cross-sectional in Coronary artery disease (n=70). Multislice cardiac computed tomography (MSCT) vs. Coronary arteriography (CA) was evaluated on Diagnostic accuracy for significant coronary artery disease. Multislice cardiac computed tomography showed high diagnostic accuracy for significant coronary artery disease, with 95% negative predictive value, 99% specificity, and 50% sensitivity.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: