Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Editor—Proof that a medical emergency team can reduce the incidence of and mortality from unexpected cardiac arrest is eagerly awaited, as such a proposal is intuitive. However, the number of such arrests can be influenced by several factors, including the number of “do not resuscitate” decisions made. Buist et al's paper fails to take this into account, and suffers from other methodological errors too.1 The study used a historical control group and was undertaken in a setting in which there was already a trend towards a reduced incidence of and mortality from cardiac arrest. Moreover, the case mix varied considerably between the two study periods. The authors' definition of cardiac arrest included patients who had not actually experienced an arrest yet excluded four who had been allocated do not resuscitate orders but for whom a call was made. Ward patients who do not have a cardiac arrest have a better outcome than those who do; hence by adopting a loose definition the study denominator has been artificially enhanced, giving a false benefit. Some patients receive cardiopulmonary resuscitation despite it being futile, and thus the resuscitation status of critically ill patients must be established. However, any increase in do not resuscitate orders inevitably reduces the incidence of and mortality from unexpected cardiac arrests. The introduction of a medical emergency team increases the number of do not resuscitate orders.2 Buist et al report that, in 1999, the medical emergency team made 13 such orders for patients who subsequently died but do not report the overall incidence of these orders in the hospital in either year studied. The study's design makes it impossible to separate the beneficial impact of the formal education process provided to ward staff from that due to specific interventions by the medical emergency team. The education may have led to better ward care or to more do not resuscitate orders being applied by staff who were not members of the team. Perhaps education alone led to the results that are being attributed to the team. The cover of the issue of the BMJ containing Buist et al's paper, showing a medical emergency team in action, suggests that the authors have confirmed a beneficial role for the team. This may be correct, as the team may have reduced the number of inappropriate cardiac arrest calls by increasing the incidence of do not resuscitate orders or by improving the education of ward staff. What is not proved is that a medical emergency team can reduce the incidence of and mortality from unexpected cardiac arrest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gary B. Smith (2002) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: