Key result
Antidepressant treatment linked to improved mood, functional status, and disability in comorbid chronic illness.
Why the study?
The clinical and functional outcomes of depression treatment in primary-care patients with chronic medical illness compared to those without such illness were unclear.
Does antidepressant treatment improve depression and functional status similarly in primary-care patients with and without chronic medical illness?
Cohort (n=439)
Does antidepressant treatment improve depression and functional status similarly in primary-care patients with and without chronic medical illness?
Initiation of depression treatment leads to significant improvements in mood, social and emotional functioning, and disability in patients with chronic medical illnesses, suggesting depression may be a stronger determinant of disability than stable chronic medical illness.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Depression treatment improves mood and disability in comorbid patients; leaves open whether slower gains in heart disease warrant tailored approaches.
BACKGROUND: In patients with chronic medical conditions, depression can be viewed as an expected reaction to illness or an independent condition requiring active treatment. We examine how clinical and functional outcomes of depression treatment compare in primary-care patients with and without chronic medical illness. METHOD: Health plan administrative data were used to identify primary-care patients initiating antidepressant treatment, including a general sample (n=204) and cohorts with ischemic heart disease (n=68), diabetes (n=93), or obstructive lung disease (n=74). Telephone interviews at baseline, 2 months, and 6 months assessed depression (Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV, Hopkins Symptom Checklist depression scale), functional status (SF-36) and days of disability because of to illness. RESULTS: At baseline, depression severity in patients with diabetes and obstructive lung disease was similar to those without medical co-morbidity, but significantly lower in those with ischemic heart disease. Social and emotional functioning were similar across all groups, but those with chronic medical illness reported greater physical impairment. All groups showed significant improvement in depression over six months, but the rate of improvement was significantly slower in those with heart disease. All groups showed significant and similar improvement in social and emotional functioning, but physical functioning showed little change. Days of disability and restricted activity improved significantly in all groups. Improvement in depression during treatment was strongly related to change in disability. CONCLUSIONS: Patients with chronic medical illness and co-morbid depression show significant improvements in mood, social and emotional functioning, and disability following initiation of depression treatment. Depression may be a stronger determinant of disability than is stable chronic medical illness.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Simon et al. (2005) conducted a cohort in Depression with and without chronic medical illness (n=439). Antidepressant treatment vs. Patients without chronic medical illness was evaluated on Depression severity, functional status, and days of disability. Antidepressant treatment in patients with chronic medical illness and co-morbid depression was associated with significant improvements in mood, social and emotional functioning, and disability.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: