Key result
NICHD criteria achieve substantial agreement with computer analysis for fetal heart-rate variability interpretation.
Why the study?
The accuracy of fetal heart-rate variability interpretation by obstetricians using NICHD criteria compared with computer-aided analysis was not well established.
Does interpretation by obstetricians using NICHD criteria accurately assess fetal heart-rate variability compared to computer-aided analysis in high-risk pregnancies?
Cross-Sectional (n=114)
Single-blind
Does interpretation by obstetricians using NICHD criteria accurately assess fetal heart-rate variability compared to computer-aided analysis in high-risk pregnancies?
Obstetricians, both residents and faculty, demonstrate substantial accuracy and agreement in interpreting fetal heart-rate variability using NICHD criteria compared to computer-aided analysis.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Obstetrician FHR variability reads show substantial computer agreement; leaves open whether NICHD criteria alter intrapartum outcomes in high-risk labor.
AIM: To evaluate the accuracy of fetal heart rate variability interpretation by obstetricians using the criteria of the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD), compared with computer-aided analysis as a gold standard. METHODS: One hundred and fourteen panels of fetal heart-rate tracings derived from electrocardiogram via scalp electrodes obtained from women with high-risk pregnancies during the intrapartum period. The tracings were interpreted using computer analysis and recorded as a gold standard. The same tracings were distributed to six observers: three residents in the third year of training and three faculty members. All observers blindly interpreted the fetal heart-rate variability without the knowledge of the computer analysis. The main outcome measures were: (i) the accuracy of fetal heart-rate variability interpretation by obstetricians using the NICHD criteria compared with computer-aided analysis was presented as a percentage value; and (ii) the agreement of fetal heart-rate variability interpretation between the obstetricians and the computer analysis using the NICHD criteria was presented as a kappa-value. RESULT: When using the computer analysis as a gold standard, the accuracy of fetal heart-rate variability interpretation in the residents group was 81.58%, 86.84% and 82.46%, respectively, with a mean of 83.62%, whereas the accuracy of the faculty members was 79.82%, 67.54% and 79.82%, respectively, with a mean of 75.73%. kappa-values, representing the agreement of interpretation, were 0.70, 0.78 and 0.72, with a mean of 0.73 +/- 0.04 among the residents, and 0.67, 0.50 and 0.68, with a mean of 0.62 +/- 0.10 among the faculty members. Agreements in the two groups were not significantly different (Student's t-test, P=0.14). CONCLUSION: Using the NICHD criteria, the accuracy and agreement of fetal heart-rate variability interpretation in the third-year residents and faculty members are substantial. There was no difference between the groups with regard to the agreement of fetal heart-rate variability interpretation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tongsong et al. (2005) conducted a cross-sectional in High-risk pregnancies (n=114). Interpretation by obstetricians using NICHD criteria vs. Computer-aided analysis was evaluated on Accuracy and agreement (kappa-value) of fetal heart-rate variability interpretation (p=0.14). Interpretation of fetal heart-rate variability using NICHD criteria showed substantial agreement with computer analysis for both residents and faculty.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: