Key result
RV-I and RV-II methods outperform occlusion and three-point techniques for estimating wave velocity and attenuation.
Why the study?
Considerable disparity exists between methods used to compute the propagation coefficient in arterial systems, with unclear sources of error affecting phase velocity and attenuation estimates.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Discrepancies in propagation coefficient derivation in literature are likely due to inaccuracy of experimental measurement techniques (like distance between sites and sampling interval under high noise) rather than the methods themselves.
Over the last few decades several methods have been used to compute the propagation coefficient, which is a complex number that provides information about the viscoelastic properties of blood vessels. Results from these methods show a considerable disparity between them and when they are compared to theoretical values. Moreover, the attenuation and phase velocity obtained by the three-point method shows more significant discrepancies than those obtained by the other methods. In order to clarify the source of the disparity of results carried out by various methods concerning the estimation of phase velocity and attenuation in the arterial network, we made investigations using numerical tool several methods. We studied, for each method, the effects of distance between measurement sites, the sampling interval and measurement errors on the determination of the propagation coefficient by each of these methods. The values of wave speed and attenuation computed by these methods were compared to the known input values. Our simulation demonstrates that the distance between measurement sites and the sampling interval may introduce significant errors when the noise becomes high. Moreover the error on the values of attenuation and phase velocity obtained by occlusion and three-point methods is significantly higher than the error on the values obtained by RV-I and RV-II methods for all experimental conditions studied within the examined frequency range. This result supports the idea that the discrepancy between studies reported in literature seems to be due to the inaccuracy of experimental measurement techniques and not associated with the methods themselves as concluded by some authors.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Abdessalem et al. (2009) studied Arterial wave propagation (numerical simulation). RV-I and RV-II methods for propagation coefficient vs. Occlusion (OCC) and three-point (3P) methods was evaluated on Accuracy of computed phase velocity and attenuation compared to theoretical input values. Numerical simulations demonstrate that the RV-I and RV-II methods are more reliable and less sensitive to noise, measurement distance, and sampling intervals than occlusion and three-point methods.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: