Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Oil- and wax-proofed cotton is sold and used on an understanding that it sheds water, with re-treatment advised in vague terms such as "from time to time" or "when water stops beading". This paper replaces the vagueness with a sizing rule. Hydrostatic resistance is modelled as decaying exponentially with wearing days, from a fresh value of 900 mm under two stated mechanisms: flexing at 10,000 flex cycles per wearing day with a decay constant of 3.0e-6 per cycle (0.030 per day), and rain wash-out at 0.008 per rain-hour at a reference intensity of 5 mm/h, scaled with intensity. Leakage is taken to begin when resistance falls below a stated threshold of 350 mm, which gives a re-treatment interval of ln(900/350) divided by the daily decay rate. The interval is 31.5 wearing days for dry wear alone, 24.9 days at 1 rain-hour per day, 17.5 days at 3 rain-hours per day, and 12.1 days at 6 rain-hours per day or at 3 rain-hours per day in 10 mm/h rain. At typical use — 3 rain-hours per day — resistance falls from 900.0 mm to 524.5 mm in 10 wearing days and crosses the threshold at 17.5 days, which is 4.4 weeks at 4 wearing days per week. Costed over a stated season of 120 wearing days and 360 rain-hours, the proofed-cloth route needs 7 treatments per season and costs $140.33 per season, or $0.390 per dry hour ($0.609 with reproofing labour valued); a stated plastic poncho at $14 replaced every 25 wearing days costs $70.00 per season, or $0.194 per dry hour — exactly half. Proofed cotton is therefore not the cheap route to staying dry on these figures; what the premium buys is durability, repairability, and a garment that remains serviceable for years, and the interval rule states how often that garment must be maintained for the waterproofing claim to remain true.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
William Alexander Aldred (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: