Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Physical education (PE) is characterised by embodied participation, social exposure, and ongoing comparison between students, making questions of inclusion, fairness, and participation particularly complex. While grouping students into pairs, teams, or working units is often treated as a routine organisational practice, such decisions shape students’ participation, recognition, and sense of belonging in significant ways. Existing approaches to grouping in PE frequently rely on procedural understandings of fairness or organisational efficiency, overlooking how grouping practices are experienced differently by students within specific relational and embodied contexts. Drawing on Nel Noddings’s ethics of care, this paper reconceptualises grouping as an ethically significant form of pedagogical decisionmaking. Engaging with debates on fairness, categorisation, and gender diversity in sport and education, the paper introduces the concept of ‘flexible grouping’, which understands grouping as an ongoing and context-sensitive process rather than a fixed organisational strategy. The argument is further illustrated through a classroom scenario demonstrating how flexible grouping may inform teachers’ responses to ethically complex situations in secondary physical education. Using the inclusion of transgender students in secondary school physical education as its primary context, the paper argues that no single grouping method can adequately address the competing demands of inclusion, fairness, safety, recognition, and meaningful participation across all pedagogical situations. It argues that ethical practice in PE therefore depends on teachers’ attentiveness and responsiveness to students’ lived experiences.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Matyáš Kubů (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: