Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background During the COVID-19 pandemic, public health requirements for physical distancing and restrictions on physical gathering significantly altered how co-design could be conducted in health care contexts, especially negatively affecting projects engaging individuals from marginalized communities. Rapid adaptations were made with varied levels of success. A conventional strategy for understanding these adaptations would have been a review of published literature. However, few detailed accounts had been published at the time, and many co-designers were still actively exploring how to adapt their methods. Objectives This research investigated co-design practices to learn what adaptations were successful in engaging marginalized communities, what adaptations might be applied in other contexts, and what might be sustained post-pandemic. Design The overall research design was a realist synthesis, focusing on what works, for whom, and in what circumstances. An initial framework of co-design principles that contribute to equitable, diverse and inclusive (EDI) participation was developed to structure the analysis of adaptations that were made. However, with changes still underway and many adaptations not published, innovations to realist methods were necessary. In addition to a literature scan, design research approaches (workshops, interviews, a Community of Practice, webinars, a Winter School, and conference presentations) were used to generate data and validate findings iteratively. Setting and participants The data collection and analysis took place mostly online. Design researchers, health researchers and design practitioners from three continents were engaged in the various activities over time. Results Adding design research approaches to the realist synthesis identified many adaptations that would otherwise not have been recorded or noticed. Substantively, there were significant numbers of successful adaptations aligned with four initial EDI principles, and three additional categories of adaptations were identified. Conclusions Adapting realist methods to include design research approaches can be fruitful, especially when the evidence and experience under investigation are actively in development. Many of the adaptations that were made during the pandemic can potentially be carried into post-pandemic co-design practice, increasing opportunities for engagement with individuals from marginalized communities. Disseminating these findings in ways that are useable by co-designers is the next step in this research.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Holyoke et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: