Key result
Manual traction alone achieves ~92% success for transvenous lead extraction with low complications.
Why the study?
Does transvenous lead extraction using manual traction without extraction tools achieve successful lead removal with an acceptable complication rate in patients with implanted cardiac leads?
Cohort (n=130)
Does transvenous lead extraction using manual traction without extraction tools achieve successful lead removal with an acceptable complication rate in patients with implanted cardiac leads?
Manual traction without extraction tools can be successfully used as an initial lead removal strategy in patients with low risk scores (LED, MB, EROS), achieving a 91.5% success rate and a 3.8% complication rate.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Captured external expert commentary on this paper, strongest first. Original sources are linked where available.
“In the current issue of Acta Cardiologica, Camci et al. present their single-centre experience with lead extraction using only manual traction without special extraction tools in 130 patients (200 leads) over a 5-year period. If manual traction was unsuccessful, they switched to femoral extraction using an ablation catheter or gooseneck snare. They showed a success rate of 91.5% complete removal.”
“The current paper confirms that the stepwise approach is valid and that simple traction can be used as a first option in many lead extraction procedures. This fact is very important to realise from a cost-effectiveness point of view, as more complex tools come with a significantly higher price. However, more efficient tools should be available and used when needed to achieve presently possible success rates.”
Manual traction achieves high success with low complications in experienced centers; leaves open comparative efficacy versus powered tools in prospective trials.
OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to describe our experience with lead extraction using manual traction. RESULTS: A total of 200 leads were extracted from 130 patients. The mean duration since implantation was 4.05 ± 4.07 years. Leads were successfully removed in 91.5% of patients. Extraction devices were required in 27 (20.8%) patients. Complications occurred in five (3.8%) patients (EROS-1: 3 [2.8%], EROS-2: 0, EROS-3: 2 [18.2%]; CONCLUSION: Lead extraction using manual traction without extraction tools achieved a 91.5% success rate and 3.8% complication rate. The LED and MB scores significantly predicted complication risk and the need for device use. An EROS score of three was associated with a high risk of complications. Manual traction is more likely to be successful in patients with low scores and may be attempted as an initial strategy (NCT07023900).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Çamcı et al. (2026) conducted a cohort in Patients with implanted cardiac leads undergoing transvenous lead extraction (n=130). Transvenous lead extraction using manual traction without extraction tools was evaluated on Successful lead removal. Transvenous lead extraction using manual traction without extraction tools achieved a 91.5% success rate and a 3.8% complication rate across 130 patients.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: