Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose This article examines the epistemological tension between researchers' prior expectations and the methodological commitment to openness in qualitative inquiry. In response to the transparency requirements associated with preregistration and registered reports, it reconceptualises the role of hypothesis in qualitative research. Design/methodology/approach Drawing primarily on hermeneutics and abductive reasoning, the article develops an Abductive Hermeneutic Framework, which it illustrates through three rounds of oral-history fieldwork on the Sino-Vietnamese border conflict. Findings Qualitative hypotheses are not propositions fixed in advance and subjected to a one-off test. Rather, they are explicitly articulated, revisable research expectations or possible explanations that encounter empirical resistance and may be revised throughout fieldwork and data analysis. Departures from researchers' prior expectations do not signify research failure; instead, they create opportunities to reformulate questions, redirect interpretation and generate theoretical insights. Originality/value The article translates the hermeneutic concept of fore-structure into a methodological process of hypothesis articulation, empirical examination, interpretive revision and theoretical reconstruction. By systematically explaining how hypotheses connect existing theory with situated experience, the Abductive Hermeneutic Framework offers a non-positivist approach to preregistration and research transparency while strengthening reflexivity, traceability and ethical responsibility in qualitative inquiry.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Baibin Yang (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: