Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Purpose Digital platforms now host massive volumes of consumer-generated content, and firms increasingly treat online reviews and structured surveys as parallel “listening systems” for assessing service quality and satisfaction. However, whether these sources can be used interchangeably as indicators of customer satisfaction remains an open empirical question. This study examines the voice–evidence gap by comparing how online reviews and survey responses represent satisfaction. Design/methodology/approach This study uses a network-based approach to examine how customer satisfaction is represented across different customer-information sources. Online reviews capture co-occurring experiential cues, whereas surveys record responses to pre-specified attributes. Study 1 analyzes 10,752 online reviews using a co-occurrence network, and Study 2 examines 506 survey responses using a partial correlation network. The study compares the relational structures derived from the two data sources. Findings The findings reveal a voice–evidence gap as an observed divergence in the relational representation of customer satisfaction across the two data sources. Customer satisfaction is embedded within clusters of co-mentioned experiential attributes in the review-based co-occurrence network but is less locally embedded within these clusters in the survey-based partial correlation network while maintaining strong overall network connectivity. In review-based networks, satisfaction aligns closely with hygiene and other experiential service cues. In survey-based networks, professionalism emerges as the principal bridging attribute linking experiential attributes to satisfaction. These findings show that relying on a single data source can yield incomplete representations of customer satisfaction. Originality/value This study contributes to marketing intelligence research by showing that consumer data sources differ not only in content but also in how they represent satisfaction relationally. By comparing relational structures across reviews and survey data, the study illustrates how different customer-information sources are associated with different relational representations of customer satisfaction.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hong‐Youl Ha (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: