Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In Justice Across Ages, Juliana Bidadanure draws our attention to inequalities between the young and old.Bidadanure's innovation is to appeal to ideas of relational inequality between age groups.Drawing on the work of Iris Marion Young (1990) and Elizabeth Anderson (1999) she argues that justice between ages will be restricted if our attention is purely concerned with distribution.She holds that relations between age groups can be damaged by problems such as domination, infantilization, paternalism and exploitation.These relational problems are deeply troublesome, even if, over the course of our lives, we find ourselves on both sides of these relations.In the book, a new form of basic income is proposed.This, she argues, will go some way to ensuring relational equality between age groups.I focus on two relational conflicts raised by Bidadanure's basic income proposal.The first conflict involves state paternalism, the second conflict involves exploitation.I argue that if Bidadanure is to resolve or mitigate this relational conflict, then it seems crucial for her to explain: (1) why her basic income proposal does not institutionalize conditions of relational inequality; or (2) why some relational inequality is a price worth paying.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nicola Mulkeen (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: