Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper explores the similarities and differences between Juliana Bidadanure's account of justice across age groups (2021) and my own (2020).While we both hold that age-based inequalities are objectionable if they undermine relational equality or cause people's opportunities to dip below a threshold level, we differ when it comes to the specific characterization of a threshold and its basis.Section 1 brings to light three salient differences and argues that in each case, my rendering of sufficiency has decisive advantages.Section 2 takes up the first difference, which concerns the specification of sufficiency as normal opportunities versus central human capabilities.Section 3 explores the second difference, which pertains to justifying sufficiency across the lifespan by appealing to prudence versus dignity.Section 4 considers the third difference, which relates to whether the standard of sufficiency is relative to a particular society or to human capabilities broadly understood.Section 5 responds to two objections.The paper concludes that while Bidadanure's account of age-group justice appropriately targets relational equality and threshold opportunity, the specification of sufficiency falls short.It does not adequately safeguard people's ability to lead nonhumiliating human lives.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nancy S. Jecker (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: