Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Modern curricula in the natural sciences stress the importance of the development of intellectual skills in the domain of critical thinking. Since such curricula are laboratory/enquiry orientated, the development of certain thought‐habits should be seen both as a prerequisite and as an outcome of science‐teaching. Teachers’ skills in this respect are usually taken for granted. Recent studies throw some doubts on such assumptions. In the study reported here, pupil‐, student‐ and teacher‐samples in Australia, South Africa and Israel responded to a test involving eight categories of logical fallacies relevant to science‐education. The results showed that the great majority of pupils in upper secondary schools either committed the logical fallacies, or simply ignored the logical structure of the test‐situations. The results obtained by post‐graduate (university) student‐teachers also left much to be desired, with post‐secondary (teachers‐college) student‐teachers in an intermediate position between the secondary‐school pupils and the university groups. It was recommended that neither the pupils’ nor the (student‐)teachers’ intellectual skills should be taken for granted, that (student‐)teachers should be made aware of the lack of such skills in their (future‐)pupils, and that teacher‐education programmes, both pre‐ and in‐service, should ensure explicit attention to this problem by preventive and/or remedial action.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
E. Jungwirth (1987) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: