Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Despite increasing efforts to assess sustainability in food systems, methodological inconsistencies and gaps in comparability, transparency, and stakeholder participation persist. This scoping review maps and synthesizes conceptual models and methodological approaches underlying existing assessment tools, including life cycle assessment (LCA), sustainability indicators, and multicriteria analysis. A systematic search of four databases (Web of Science, Scopus, PubMed, and Embase) identified 1,487 documents, with 50 selected for in-depth analysis. The findings reveal regional disparities, with Europe leading holistic food system assessments, while Africa and Asia show a latent demand for context-specific approaches. Sustainability remains a polysemic concept, often lacking a clear definition. However, most frameworks integrate food security and nutrition, and sustainable diets as guiding concepts. At the national level, tools emphasize broad sustainability outcomes—such as food insecurity, poverty, greenhouse gas emissions, carbon and water footprints, animal welfare, and food loss and waste—while local-scale tools focus on supply chain processes, including production, resource and waste management, transportation, and food processing. Although indicators generally align with the environmental, social, economic, and health and nutrition domains, further refinement is needed for internal activities. The limited disclosure of criteria applied, types of stakeholders involved, and the scarce use of quantitative methods raise concerns about bias and reproducibility. This review defines minimal parameters to guide future sustainability assessment tools for food systems, revealing trade-offs in scale, level, and scope. • A baseline trend was identified in food system sustainability assessments. • Scale, level, and scope choices shape the applicability and depth of analysis. • Internal food system indicators remain limited in existing frameworks. • Mixed methods and context-specific tools are needed for robust analysis. • Transparency and stakeholder participation remain critical gaps.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Garcia et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: