Key result
Eligible but nonincluded patients in an acute coronary syndrome registry had higher in-hospital mortality compared to included patients, demonstrating substantial selection bias.
Why the study?
Does incomplete recruitment in acute coronary syndrome registries introduce systematic bias in clinical outcomes and relative risk estimates?
Observational (n=4,704)
Yes
Does incomplete recruitment in acute coronary syndrome registries introduce systematic bias in clinical outcomes and relative risk estimates?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Incomplete recruitment in acute coronary syndrome registries introduces substantial systematic bias, as missed patients have significantly higher mortality and receive fewer recommended therapies.
BACKGROUND: The risk of selection bias in registries and its consequences are relatively unexplored. We sought to assess selection bias in a recent registry about acute coronary syndrome and to explore the way of conducting and reporting patient registries of acute coronary syndrome. METHODS AND RESULTS: We analyzed data from patients of a national acute coronary syndrome registry undergoing an audit about the comprehensiveness of the recruitment/inclusion. Patients initially included by hospital investigators (n=3265) were compared to eligible nonincluded (missed) patients (n=1439). We assessed, for 25 exposure variables, the deviation of the in-hospital mortality relative risks calculated in the initial sample from the actual relative risks. Missed patients were of higher risk and received less recommended therapies than the included patients. In-hospital mortality was almost 3 times higher in the missed population (9.34% [95% CI, 7.84 to 10.85] versus 3.9% [95% CI, 2.89 to 4.92]). Initial relative risks diverged from the actual relative risks more than expected by chance (P<0.05) in 21 variables, being higher than 10% in 17 variables. This deviation persisted on a smaller degree on multivariable analysis. Additionally, we reviewed a sample of 129 patient registries focused on acute coronary syndrome published in thirteen journals, collecting information on good registry performance items. Only in 38 (29.4%) and 48 (37.2%) registries was any audit of recruitment/inclusion and data abstraction, respectively, mentioned. Only 4 (3.1%) authors acknowledged potential selection bias because of incomplete recruitment. CONCLUSIONS: Irregular inclusion can introduce substantial systematic bias in registries. This problem has not been explicitly addressed in a substantial number of them.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ferreira‐González et al. (2009) conducted an observational in Acute Coronary Syndrome (n=4,704). Noninclusion in registry (missed patients) vs. Included patients was evaluated on In-hospital mortality. Eligible but nonincluded patients in an acute coronary syndrome registry had higher in-hospital mortality compared to included patients, demonstrating substantial selection bias.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: