Black Representation Through the University to Audit Firm Pipeline

ABSTRACT This study evaluates the auditing profession's diversity outcomes by comparing diversity along the university to job pipeline for auditing and other comparison disciplines. My tests show consistently anomalous outcomes for Black people in the audit labor pipeline, and therefore, I focus the study on them. I find that, among college freshmen planning to major in accounting, Black college freshmen are significantly overrepresented relative to freshmen planning to major in other business disciplines or nonbusiness disciplines. I find evidence of Black underrepresentation in the audit labor pipeline at every subsequent point: among accounting bachelor's and master's degree recipients, in the audit firm recruiting process, and among young professional auditors. My evidence of especially sharp Black attrition from accounting degree programs is, to my knowledge, novel. Although I lack sufficient data to pinpoint the mechanisms causing this sharp Black attrition from accounting degree programs, my findings are inconsistent with the popular theory that Black college students are distinctively uninterested in pursuing accounting education. It is not yet possible to make well‐targeted and data‐driven policy prescriptions to counter Black attrition from accounting degree programs because its causes are not well understood. Universities could contribute to the diagnosis process by systematically collecting and distributing data characterizing when and why students select away from accounting. My findings on audit firm recruiting are inconsistent with popular theories that Black underrepresentation in audit firms is attributable to overtly racially biased recruiters or lower interest among Black accounting graduates in pursuing careers in audit firms. Rather, my findings conform best with unintentionally biased recruiting by audit firms, which appear to make recruiting investments using outdated definitions of school quality. My evidence suggests that campus‐recruiting leaders within audit firms have the opportunity to hire more Black auditors without reducing the quality of the schools from which they recruit.