Key result
Automated 3D-PISA echocardiography provided similar regurgitant volume estimates compared to standard 2D-PISA in the overall mitral valve prolapse population, but overestimated regurgitation in patients with asymmetric flow convergence regions.
Why the study?
Data assessing mitral regurgitation severity in mitral valve prolapse using 3D-PISA are scarce.
Does 3D-PISA accurately quantify regurgitant volume compared to 2D-PISA and CMR in patients with mitral valve prolapse?
Observational (n=54)
Single-blind
No
Does 3D-PISA accurately quantify regurgitant volume compared to 2D-PISA and CMR in patients with mitral valve prolapse?
3D-PISA provides analogous evaluation of mitral regurgitation compared to 2D-PISA but overestimates regurgitant volume in cases of asymmetric flow convergence or when compared to CMR.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
3D-PISA warrants caution in asymmetric flow convergence; leaves open accuracy versus CMR in mitral valve prolapse.
Three-dimensional transthoracic echocardiography (3D-TTE) provides a semi-automated proximal isovelocity surface area method (3D-PISA) to obtain quantitative parameters. Data assessing regurgitation severity in mitral valve prolapse (MVP) are scarce, so we assessed the 3D-PISA method compared with 2D-PISA and cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) and the role of an eccentricity index. We evaluated the 3D-PISA method for assessing MR in 54 patients with MVP (57 ± 14 years; 42 men; 12 mild/mild-moderate; 12 moderate-severe; and 30 severe MR). Role of an asymmetric (i.e. eccentricity index ≥ 1.25) flow convergence region (FCR) and inter-modality consistency were then assessed. 3D-PISA derived regurgitant volume (RVol) showed a good correlation with 2D-PISA and CMR derived parameters (r = 0.86 and r = 0.81, respectively). The small mean differences with 2D-PISA derived RVol did not reach statistical significance in overall population (5.7 ± 23 ml, 95% CI - 0.6 to 12; p = 0.08) but differed in those with asymmetric 3D-FCR (n = 21; 2D-PISA: 72 ± 36 ml vs. 3D-PISA: 93 ± 47 ml; p = 0.001). RVol mean values were higher using PISA methods (CMR 57 ± 33 ml; 2D-PISA 73 ± 39 ml; and 3D-PISA 79 ± 45 ml) and an overestimation was observed when CMR was used as reference (2D-PISA vs. CMR: mean difference: 15.8 ml [95% CI 10-22, p < 0.001]; and 3D-PISA vs. CMR: 21.5 ml [95% CI 14-29, p < 0.001]). Intra- and inter-observer reliability was excellent (ICC 0.91-0.99), but with numerically lower coefficient of variation for 3D-PISA (8%-10% vs. 2D-PISA: 12%-16%). 3D-PISA method for assessing regurgitation in MVP may enable analogous evaluation compared to standard 2D-PISA, but with overestimation in case of asymmetric FCR or when CMR is used as reference method.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Spampinato et al. (2021) conducted an observational in Mitral valve prolapse with organic mitral regurgitation (n=54). 3D-PISA echocardiography vs. 2D-PISA echocardiography and Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance was evaluated on Mean difference in regurgitant volume (RVol) between 3D-PISA and 2D-PISA (MD 5.7 ml, 95% CI -0.6 to 12, p=0.08). Automated 3D-PISA echocardiography provided similar regurgitant volume estimates compared to standard 2D-PISA in the overall mitral valve prolapse population, but overestimated regurgitation in patients with asymmetric flow convergence regions.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: